Following a review in the newspaper, I picked up The Collaborators, a spy novel by Michael Idov. I read and enjoyed it, but it was just OK, not as great as I would’ve expected from the review. So, that’s fine, tastes differ, but in this case I thought it would be possible to go deeper, by considering more carefully what I expect to see in a spy novel.
Like all genre fiction, spy stories have their conventions. But maybe because the spy form is a bit narrower than, say, crime fiction or science fiction, its conventions are more constrained.
What follows is a list of the expected features of spy fiction. Most are positive from my perspective as a reader, some are negative, others neutral. But I consider all these to be typical features of the genre.
Before going on, let me situate my tastes. My favorite spy novel ever is Tinker Tailer Soldier Spy, I’m also a big fan of Eric Ambler and Graham Greene (not a genre writer like Ambler or Le Carre but he did write some classic spy stories), and my favorite modern spy novels are the first two Tourist books by Olen Steinhauer. I also love the Slow Horses books—yeah, call me a middlebrow, I don’t care! I’ll refer to some of the above literature when discussing the features below. And I also enjoyed Black Bag and The Americans, but I won’t talk too much about movies or TV in this post.
Disorientation
Spy novels are like science fiction and crime fiction in that they get much of their power by inducing in readers a feeling of disorientation. In science fiction, this might be a future or alien society or just something unexplained entering our normal world, a puzzle to be solved. As for crime and detective stories, they’re called “mystery” for a reason. You start with a pleasurable feeling that you don’t know which way is up, and then, as you read, various mysteries get resolved and new mysteries surface—maybe enough to give room for a sequel. (I heard an interview with Mick Herron where he said that he purposely introduces mysterious elements to his books without them being plotted in, just to give him room to maneuver in future books. Kind of like those one-story houses with rebar sticking out, in preparation for the eventual second level to be built.)
You might think that there’d be no point to re-reading genre fiction: once you know all the spoilers, the suspense is gone. But the fun can go the other way too: reading the story without the initial disorientation is an entirely different experience. It’s actually pretty amazing to read Tinker Tailor, after knowing how the story is going to play out.
Disorientation is harder to pull off in a series. The Slow Horses books take place in a pretty constrained universe, and it doesn’t take long to realize that Jackson Lamb is a good guy, etc., so in this series the disorientation has to be created from the new plot for each individual book. Which is fine but it’s not the full experience. The Tourist series achieves continuing disorientation by upping the stakes each time, but after the second book, the unfortunate result is that he’s kind of run out of rope. In retrospect I think it was a mistake for Steinhauer to have killed off the Tourist program at the end of book 1. It was fine in that book, but it gave him less to work with going forward. In contrast, Herron does much better at keeping the stakes high in each book without escalating.
Mildly exotic surroundings
Much of The Collaborators takes place in Latvia and Moscow, and, yes, these are exotic locations—but not too exotic. As readers, we have some idea of what to expect in post-Soviet landscapes.
This is par for the course: just about all the spy novels I’ve read will put the characters in an interesting locale—indeed, sense of place is an important aspect of spy fiction, which makes sense given the connection between spying and nationality—but it’s usually not anything too unfamiliar. I’m not sure why it should be the case, except that spy stories are by their nature international, but it seems like a pretty consistent pattern to me.
Moral seriousness
At the simplest level (for example, Graham Greene’s early novel, The Confidential Agent), a spy story is about confounding the knavish plots of the bad guys. Then there’s mid- and late-period Eric Ambler, where both sides might be amoral schemers, but the reader is still made aware of the stakes: innocent lives are involved. Le Carre and his successors take it to the next level, where even the good guys are reflecting on their culpability. But, even without that sort moral ambiguity, it can’t just be a game. There has to be a purpose to it. One reason that Chris Pavone’s The Expats left a bad aftertaste to me was that I didn’t feel that air of seriousness. Yes, there was peril, and I cared about the characters while the story was playing out, but it seemed more like an adventure than something important, and when it was all over they just seemed like a bunch of killers to me, and I was annoyed that I was supposed to be rooting for them. In contrast, Slow Horses is a lot of fun, but there’s always an underlying sense that they’re doing this for a reason.
Sexism
Not a good thing, but this is just the tradition in most of literature. Even more so in espionage, where the overwhelming majority of real-world agents have been men. But it’s not just that. Le Carre’s casual sexism has been long noted, and it’s taken a while for authors in this genre to catch up to modern sensibilities. Even the recent book by Michael Idov has trad tropes such as referring to the male lead by his last name and the female lead by her first name, also various descriptions of female characters as being amazingly beautiful. Can’t a woman just be attractive to some guys—does she always have to be such a looker (or the opposite, as with Tinker Tailor’s Connie Sachs)? The recent spy novels that best handled this, in my opinion, are the Tourist books. I have a feeling that Steinhauer had to do some “affirmative action” here, populating his story with more major female characters than would exist in real life, but it worked for me. Similarly with Slow Horses: I get the impression that Herron worked hard to get enough woman characters into the mix, and I also think that the effort paid off.
Good action scenes
People don’t always think about this for books (as opposed to movies), but there is such a thing as a compellingly-written action scene. As in a movie, you need emotion, micro-suspense, the parallel placement of action and thought (i.e., you get a sense of the characters’ thinking and decision making while the action is happening), along with some legibility of who’s doing what when, who’s in the scene, what might come next, etc. Also a delicate balance between excitement and plausibility: on one hand, you don’t want to just see some superhero punching everyone out; on the other, a bit of fancy footwork is appreciated.
I’m no expert on how to write a good action scene, but I can recognize it when I see it. The Tourist books have some great action scenes: the bit where he breaks into the Paris apartment in book 1, the art heist in book 2 . . . just so well done. The Slow Horses books have lots of good action and chase scenes. They’re not uniformly perfect—some verge on slapstick—but the best scenes in those books are a hundred times better than Jack Reacher mauling some bad guy. Le Carre also does it well. He doesn’t have much straight-up violence, and when he does, he doesn’t do it so well, actually, but he has compelling action scenes. For example, the episode in Tinker Tailor where Peter Guillam is sneaking the file out of the Circus library, that’s done perfectly.
Eric Ambler’s action scenes aren’t bad, but most of the drama in his books comes from the explanations, not the action. And I don’t recall Graham Greene being particularly good at action scenes either. Here’s a theory: Good action scenes came originally from the movies, and then authors figured out how to capture the same feeling in prose. Not that movies always do it well; for example, the action scenes in John Wick seemed pretty bad to me. And, for that matter, Star Wars had excellent special effects but poor action scenes, just a bunch of faceless baddies aiming their blasters at Luke and missing.
I was not impressed by the action scenes in The Collaborators. There’s a car chase in Moscow that’s not bad but nor is it so great, and the shootout in the building where the hero works isn’t done well at all. It was just the good guys being heroes.
The interesting thing is that it’s hard to write a good action scene, in the same way that it’s hard to direct a good action scene in a movie, where you have a sense at all times of who’s doing what, where the weapons are, what options the characters have, etc. An action novel that works is similar to a movie with good production values, which doesn’t necessarily mean a big budget, but it does require some care and some respect for the audience—no Netflix-style narration of the action, but rather a sort of compact with the reader.
Moral ambiguity
One thing that distinguishes Cold War and post-Cold War spy novels from other forms of genre fiction is that there’s almost always a sense, not of moral equivalence exactly—you’ll typically get the sense that we’re the good guys—but a sense that spying and deceit take you to the edge of morality, and that it’s important that “we,” in fighting “them,” don’t “become” them. In early Graham Greene and early Eric Ambler, it was simpler—we’re defending ourselves from the fascists—but after the end of the second world war, there was no clear line. Even when we’re fighting against universally-recognized baddies such as ISIS or Putin’s Russia or whatever, there’s some sense that (a) there are some reasonable people on the other side, and (b) sometimes our side uses inappropriate tactics of “the cure is worse than the disease” variety. Just about all the spy novels I’ve read have this sense of ambiguity, not quite a symmetry between the two sides, but a sense that each side has some good and some bad that can’t really be untangled. I’m sure there are some spy stories that are straight-up cops and robbers, but those wouldn’t be the sort that I would read.
Tradecraft
One of the great pleasures of spy stories is how we get convincing and seemingly realistic descriptions of surveillance, dead drops, jargon, and so forth. All the spy fiction we’re discussing here does this. Le Carre is the master here, but all the others do it well. It’s the price of admission. No tradecraft and it’s not really part of the genre.
Betrayals
This is another one that goes with the territory. Traitors and moles, also intelligence services that sacrifice their own agents (as in The Spy Who Came in from the Cold), all sorts of backstabbers. Some of this comes straight from reality, with Tinker Tailor being a sort of retelling of the Cambridge Five, but, even more than that, it’s inherent in the subject matter. To spy is to act deceptively.
Plot twists
A twisty plot is not a necessity in a spy novel. The Spy Who Came in from the Cold and Tinker Tailor had twisty plots, but some of Eric Ambler’s novels are pretty straightforward. Their plots have surprises and revelations but not big Gone Girl-style twists that cause you to reevaluate everything that came before. The thing with plot twists, though, is you have to manage them well. If you, the reader, can anticipate the twist before it happens, that’s death to the plot. The Collaborators failed for me on those grounds. I couldn’t see everything that was coming, but the big twists were telegraphed.
Loyalty to people versus loyalty to country
This one’s essential. Whether the hero is an insider or a freelancer, a bureaucrat or a cowboy, a Clint Eastwood type or a sensitive new age guy, he has to choose between his friends and his country, and it’s essential that this not be an easy choice.
The hero is an underdog
Underdogs are sympathetic characters. James Bond is not an underdog, but he’s the exception that proves the rule. John Le Carre, Len Deighton, etc., have all been characterized as writing anti-James-Bond novels, but at this point Ian Fleming is the outlier, and when I think of spy stories, I don’t think of James Bond—yes, he’s a spy, but I think of his adventures as an entirely different genre, or, should I say, a form of male wish-fulfillment that’s less interesting to me.
I’d say that most literature puts in some effort to establish the hero as an underdog, starting off behind the eight ball and needing to overcome various challenges. The Collaborators does this too, but not in an effective way. I was somehow reminded of the movie Swingers, which I loved, but which did the annoying thing of having its hero walk around wearing a Queens College sweatshirt. What a man of the people, huh? In real life, though, the actor in question, who was also the author of the screenplay, did go to Queens College! His working-class cred was legit, but I was so used to poseurs that when I saw the sweatshirt in the movie, I cringed.
Novels, not short stories
Successful spy stories are almost always novel-length. Maybe because, in addition to setting up the plot and characters, a good spy story creates its own world, a parallel universe with the Secret Service, international conspiracies, and so forth. Tinker Tailor created the mythical Circus (yes, I know this was not the first book set in the Smiley universe, but the previous volumes in the series gave you very little backstory), Slow Horses set up a world-within-a-world of British intelligence, The Tourist created this cool clandestine program, and so forth. Indeed, one reason The Tourist series started falling apart after the second volume was that it set up too much of its backstory at the beginning, and then it had nowhere to go but to escalate.
But is the espionage genre special? Novels dominate short stories in all areas of fiction and have done so for a long time, at least since the decline of the sorts of mass-circulation magazines that published the stories of F. Scott Fitzgerald and others in the mid-twentieth century. After the war, the Golden Age of magazine science fiction stories was nearly a decade old, and the Golden Age of mysteries was mostly in novel form; indeed, you’d have to go back to the era of Sherlock Holmes to find a time that short stories were dominant.
With literature, all is different now: fiction is no longer a form of mass entertainment, so the goal is to appeal to niche audiences, not to grab the commuter who will buy a book off the rack at the train station. In any case, for the foreseeable future we can expect the written spy story tradition to continue in the form of novels.
Cynicism
This is kind of related to the themes of moral ambiguity, underdogs, and betrayal mentioned above, but slightly different that it’s more a matter of tone. The hard-bitten hero has his pangs of conscience and he cares about the cosseted civilians he’s protecting, but nothing surprises him. This attitude seems pretty much universal in spy stories. The only exception I can think of is the movie Three Days of the Condor, where Robert Redford seems legitimately shocked by the bad things going around him.
Balance between realism and fantasy
This one’s tricky. On one hand, a key part of the appeal of spy fiction (again, James Bond aside) is its verisimilitude, the sense that you’re getting a look into a gritty aspect of the world that you wouldn’t otherwise know about, indeed something closer to the “real world” than what we see every day. It’s the opposite of Agatha Christie—nothing against her books, they’re great, it’s just that she deliberately puts you in an artificial world (as do Conan Doyle, Rex Stout, and all the rest), whereas the setting of spy stories, even when clearly made up, are supposed to represent something about the structures underlying our world.
On the other hand, as readers we want excitement and good production values; see “Good action scenes,” above. The Americans was convincing in many ways, but it wasn’t so plausible that these sleeper agents would be karate-kicking their way through death-defying fights every few weeks. Le Carre did the best with keeping the action plausible, but a bit of fantasy in a novel is fine too. I enjoyed the implausible elaborate schemes in Eric Ambler novels and the stunning action scenes in the Tourist novels. But The Collaborators went too far in the fantasy direction. At one point the hero beats somebody up in a public place for just about no reason, and everybody’s like, OK, that’s cool, he’s just a passionate guy. This was more like a Sylvester Stallone movie than what I’d expect to see in a spy novel. Actions should have consequences.
Serviceable writing
In my reading, Graham Greene is a better writer than Eric Ambler, who in turn is a better writer than John Le Carre. By “better,” I mean deeper but also just more fun and interesting to read the sentence and paragraphs. But Le Carre (and the other writers named above) are just fine. Even Michael Idov, who has some really clunky prose—I blame this in part on the disappearance of editing in the modern publishing era—it doesn’t really matter. Some of the notes are jarring but ultimately that’s minor in my judgment of the book. The purpose of spy-novel prose is to convey the action and the story, and, for this, the writing just needs to be above the bar. In that way, it’s similar to other genre fiction: when you get excellent prose, that’s a benefit, and it can make up for flaws elsewhere in the book, but it’s not a necessary or characteristic feature of the genre.
Protecting one’s own comes first
We were joking about this after watching a bunch of episodes of the excellent TV series, Le Bureau des Légendes: The main job of the intelligence officers in the show seems to be to clean up after their own mistakes, rescue their agents in peril, etc. But, come to think about it, that’s so often the case in spy stories. Tinker Tailor is all about finding the mole whose biggest crime is to have betrayed his fellow operatives. The Tourist is mostly about the main character trying to stay alive, while the baddies are out there killing other agents. The heaviest emotions in the Slow Horses series are when Lamb is protecting or avenging his “joes.” And so forth. The Collaborators follows this pattern: what upsets the hero the most is when his spy buddies get whacked, and most of the action is about him avenging them and protecting his girlfriend. It’s all a kind of circular thing where the justification for the intelligence agencies is that they are needed to protect their own officers.
Anything else?
There are probably some other characteristic features of spy novels that I’m missing.






















