From junk science (largely non-political) to junk medical treatments (mostly associated with the far-right): A financial connection

Paul Krugman writes:

Last week the Food and Drug Administration refused to review Moderna’s new mRNA-based flu vaccine. They didn’t reject it based on evidence; they wouldn’t even look at it, in line with RFK Jr.’s evidence-free, dogmatic assertion that mRNA technology, which gave us Covid vaccines, is useless and harmful.

The motivations behind the crusade against clean energy and the crusade against vaccines are also similar. The conspiracy-theorizing hostility to science and expertise in general that underpins both movements also predisposes people to become right-wing extremists, which means that their movements are now in power. The headline on a 2023 article in The Guardian captured this perfectly: “‘Everything you’ve been told is a lie’: Inside the wellness-to-fascism pipeline.”

In both cases it’s crucial to follow the money.

It may seem strange to think of the wellness industry as a corrupt and corrupting force comparable to the fossil-fuel sector. But wellness is big business. McKinsey estimates that U.S. spending on wellness is running at around $500 billion a year, while spending on nutritional supplements alone was close to $70 billion last year.

And sellers of nutritional supplements, unlike companies selling pharmaceuticals, are effectively allowed to make false, outlandish claims about what their products do. . . .

I [Krugman] wrote about this almost five years ago. The relationship between quack medicine and right-wing extremism has a long history. As the historian Rick Perlstein has documented, extremists have been marketing medical snake oil, and snake oil purveyors have been financially supporting extremism, since the days when misinformation had to be disseminated through paper newsletters. This mutually beneficial relationship continued through the eras of talk radio, cable TV, and now podcasts.

It’s interesting that Krugman says that “the relationship between quack medicine and right-wing extremism has a long history.” My impression is that, before very recently, there was no correlation between political ideology and belief in quack medicine. That doesn’t mean that Krugman’s statement is false, however. There could well also be a longstanding relationship between quack medicine and left-wing views, even if not a longstanding financial relationship of the form discussed by Krugman.

In any case, Krugman’s remarks reminded me of something I’ve been wondering about: Is there a through line from B.S. numbers in junk science to B.S. numbers coming from the government? My feeling was that the past couple of decades have seen a disturbing toleration of junk science coming from credentialed or quasi-credentialed academic sources: things like the claim that attractive parents are 36% more likely to have girl babies, or that women are three times more likely to wear red or pink clothing during certain times of the month, or that scientific citations are worth $100,000 each, or that grandmasters burn 6000 calories during a chess game. Or, for that matter, the support in the elite media for the idea that UFOs are space aliens.

None of the items in the above paragraph are particularly political, and media promotion of bullshit arguments is nothing new; I still have a vivid memory from my childhood in the 1970s of the Bermuda triangle, Noah’s ark, ancient astronauts, and other wacky-but-mainstream ideas. It’s a little different, now, though, in that the old junk science was done by outsiders, whereas the new junk science is both performed and promoted by prominent academics, as I discussed in my post, Junk Science Then and Now.

One thing that came up in the comments to the above post that the entire academic sector is much bigger than it used to be. Meanwhile, book publishing is smaller. Back in the 1970s you could get rich selling a few million copies of Chariots of the Gods or whatever. Nowadays books don’t sell so well, but you can make a fine living as a professor at a university with possibility of lots more money from paid speaking engagements. So this creates the incentive and the opportunity for junk-science entrepreneurs within elite academia.

I followed that up with a post, Junk science becomes more professionalized. Meanwhile, conspiracy theories are being more associated with the center-right and right, politically. How does all this fit together? I’m not sure.

And I’m still not sure. But one thing I hadn’t considered in that post are the direct financial incentives for quack medical treatments. This is only a small part of junk science, but arguably it’s one of the most consequential parts. Shooting down vaccines is a lot more serious than stupid attention-grabbing crap about citations or chess players or whatever.

Even there, though . . . yeah, maybe there’s a connection. If you’re willing to take the word of some Stanford authority telling you lies about chess playing and calories, is this really so far from taking the word of some other Stanford professor who’s trying to sell you supplements, or trying to talk you out of taking a vaccine? All of these things represent a mystical, anti-scientific attitude, where it be vaccine scaremongering or beliefs of magical energy expenditure, and that opens the door to whatever supplements or potions they’re promoting. After all, if you can really burn days’ worth of calories in a chess game, or heal faster just using your mind, then, sure, various quack remedies are just as plausible.

So I do think there’s something there. And Krugman’s point about the finances is interesting.

Is there an alternative universe in which it’s left-wing media, rather than right-wing media, that are supported by the quack-remedies industry, in which case we’d see a different ideological lineup? Maybe president Harris would’ve appointed RFKJ to head the nation’s health policy, etc.?

This sounds kinda farfetched, but maybe not. There’s not a lot of leftwing media now, and whatever is there is not partisan in the mode of Fox News, Alex Jones, etc., but a few decades ago every city had an alternative weekly, and almost all of them were on the left. I think they made a lot of their money with advertising from music venues and the sex trade. I don’t recall seeing a lot of ads for dietary supplements but maybe it could’ve gone that way? Indeed, perhaps if supplements had sustained the alt-weeklies, we’d still have a robust left-wing media in this country?

On the other hand, there is a logic to the music and sex ads going in the alt-weeklies and dietary supplements and gold (now crypto, I guess) being advertised on conservative outlets. Music and sex are hobbies of the young, whereas it’s the old people with the ailments (to require the supplements) and the free cash (that they could spend on gold). Now there’s lots of talk about right-wing influencers among the young, but it’s my impression that the right-wing ecosystem sustained itself over the decades through its audience of oldsters.

So lots to chew on here.

25 thoughts on “From junk science (largely non-political) to junk medical treatments (mostly associated with the far-right): A financial connection”

  1. I’m not at all sure about the nature of advertising on left vs right leaning media. I glanced at CNN and FOX who I consider mainstream news media on opposite sides of the spectrum. Then I looked at Breitbart and The Hill as more extreme versions of the same. As far as I can tell, the nature of what is advertised (e.g. tech products, outdoor wear, health products, etc.) did not look different to me. Part of the complication is that it is hard to identify the ads separately from the “news.” Many news items are opinion pieces and it is hard to detect whether there is a money trail associated with these. For my limited research skills in this area, identifying the money trail is opaque, if not a black box.

    I do think it would be an interesting study to examine the advertising and story content of various media. But not easy work, I think. Network television is another case study. It appears that much of the advertising is drug-related, reflecting the age profile of the viewers but with little political slant that I can detect. Similar for my local television news (strangely dominated by personal injury lawyers beside the myriad home repair companies). So, my casual empiricism does not detect any clear difference in the types of advertising in relation to political leanings. Maybe others can speak to this. Better yet would be any actual research about this.

  2. Of course, just a few months ago RFK, jr. believed that glyphosate caused cancer, but he has changed his mind. Perhaps, Moderna’s mRNA vaccines will get a second look at some point. I advise the company to put Eric Trump on their board of directors. This would not be a right versus left move. They would simply recognize that the godfather has to wet his beak.
    The left/right dichotomy is not always applicable.

    • oncodoc –

      “Perhaps, Moderna’s mRNA vaccines will get a second look at some point.”

      Fwiw, Prasad later reversed his decision.

      It’s worth noting, however, even if Prasad’s putative ethical concerns held for people over 65+ (who can get the high-dose vaccine), insisting on a high-dose comparator as the only acceptable standard eliminated a potentially viable option for those under 65, where high-dose vaccines aren’t licensed or standard of care. They haven’t even been tested with that younger cohort. Standard-dose was the relevant benchmark for that group, and the trial showed clear superiority in that group. Blanket rejection based on the requirement of the high-dose as the comparator was almost surely a function of ideology about mRNA vaccines, and vaccines more generally. You can’t just ignore the Bobby context.

      If I was all conspiracy-minded, I’d point out the pushback from huge investors like Blackstone Life Sciences, which committed some $750 million to Moderna’s mRNA influenza vaccine program.

      But I’m not conspiracy-minded so I won’t mention that.

  3. I think the causation arrow you imply is reversed. It is more likely that various businesses will identify current trends and then appear in whatever form to sell the products.
    Whole Foods was established by a couple of your proverbial meat-and-potatoes Texans. They didn’t care who the audience was.
    Smart people know how to exploit uncertainty in science for profit and this blog sometimes points that out. Most topics in Bio-Med sciences (except some basic research) use the same inappropriate statistics like the rest of them (pop Psych.) to mask uncertainty in the best case and to misrepresent what findings mean in the worst case. We don’t have a complete picture of how a single cell works, let alone when they come in systems, tissues, organs, as they do. Yet, when we listen to medical establishment it feels like we do. I understand it’s the best we got and I am fine with that, but I want a proper disclosure of uncertainty, which requires a decent knowledge of Statistics/Probability both on the practitioner and the patient.

    When it comes to public measures like vaccination, diet, etc. your average Joe Public doesn’t know that certain findings are population averages and may or may not apply to him exactly. Of every 1M people that receive a routine flu or any other vaccine each year, one may get a vaccine-induced GBS (it says that on the tin basically) , but at the individual level, there is no way to predict it. So when your ‘health care professional’ states that ‘doctor has carefully balanced risks and benefits and recommends X and Y”, Joe Public doesn’t know that those risks and benefits are figures obtained at population level for a particular procedure or disease, not within each individual patient.

  4. Andrew: I think you’re missing a bunch of factors. One is that the Religious Right is a very powerful faction within the Republican Party, but the hippie-granola Left barely registers with the Democratic Party (pun intended). I understand why you focus on junk science, but it’s just not the vector, because it requires someone to care about science in the first place. The stuff RFK Jr. is pushing comes more of out the fear of science, and hatred of expertise, that the Republican Party and right-wing ecosystem has been pushing intensely – and it didn’t start with Trump at all. There’s a whole sociology of this stuff.

    • I agree with all of this, but to connect with Krugman, there is another important distinction to draw, between paid advertising, where the revenue comes from the advertiser, and scams directed at the audience. As PK and others (esp. Rick Perlstein) have documented, for decades one of the main revenue sources for far right media has been “alternative” wellness products marketed directed through the broadcasters themselves. This has been profoundly cynical from the get go, so the ongoing cynicism shouldn’t surprise us. In a way, Trump himself represents the apotheosis of this approach; he is all scam and huckster, and his constituency foots the bill.

  5. The El Nino – Southern Oscillation was discovered in the late 60s, shortly before I started graduate school, and a lot of time and effort was wasted looking for other “teleconnections” in climate data. If I remember right, some of this junk got published. This kind of work would not have been possible without computers, so my guess is that computers, along with over-reliance of statistical significance, allowed for the rise of the kind of junk science Andrew is talking about.

    I’ll also argue that there are other kinds of junk science. For example, for decades geologists in the US did not accept continental drift even though there was good evidence for it (see Naomi Oreskes, The Rejection of Continental Drift), and many now forgotten papers got published in this period trying to explain the geological consequences of continental drift. If a field of science goes off on a bum steer for awhile (see Kuhn, The Structure of Scientific Revolutions), junk papers of this sort ensue.

  6. Anti-Vax stuff was left-coded before Covid, I believe. I remember a study of on-line disinformation sources from about 15 years ago that whittled it down to a couple of dozen sites, which peddled Anti- Vax stuff for the left and Climate Change Denial for the Right, but which were all pretty Russia positive.

    Russia’s been playing in this space for decades. There are stories of UFO – themed UseNet forms being seeded by Russia/USSR sources. If you claimed some facility was hiding aliens in ice you could convince a few kooks to spy on their own country. And just before pandemic US arrested some guy living near Roswell for being a Russian asset, I believe. He was devoting his life to revealing the truth about the site.

    More interesting new development is how archeology is getting sucked into the Culture Wars, with all the Gobekli Tepe ancient aliens nonsense on Rogan and elsewhere. Reminds me of how Climate Scientists were attacked 15 yrs ago. Swear to God next Trump administration starts jailing archeologists because they won’t reveal where the UFOs from Atlantis are hidden.

  7. I am thinking of the prevalence of pre-covid vaccine hesitancy within certain affluent, left-wing, alt-health communities. The crunchy granola set. These would have been the people at who the disinfo was aimed at. I admit they may not be the majority of “The Left”. Anti-vax seemed fairly niche before covid. I think you could argue it was more a left-wing niche, and the disinfo was meant to appeal to that set.

    • Michael:

      As Seth indicates in his comment above, I think what you’ve seen is a product of availability bias. Also a counterintuitive or “hippie-punching” bias in the news media: the idea that these holier-than-thou lefties are actually doing something stupid like vaccine denial, that’s the kind of contrarian story that the news media loves to run. Just as they also love running stories of conservative clerics caught in sex scandals.

      My argument is not that antivax people were a majority or even a substantial minority of the left; rather, my point is that, pre-covid, antivax attitudes appear to be as prevalent among the right as among the left (but maybe a bit less prevalent among people outside the political extremes).

  8. I’m not sure about the overall thesis, but I do have some relevant data points:
    1) It is well-known that both fossil fuel and tobacco have long funded conservative think tanks.
    See p.39 of ttps://www.desmog.com/wp-content/uploads/files/fake2.pdf

    2) Of course, Big Tobacco owned major food companies for a few decades and taught them much about addictive products.
    UCSF’s Laura Schmidt: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bJjvxosuWZQ
    I have no idea if Big Tobacco also invested in “wellness” products, but worth exploring.

    3) In CA,
    SB277 (2015) required vaccinations for school, only exemption medical
    SB7 (2016) raised legal tobacco age to 21.
    I looked at the vote of CA Senate + Assembly.
    80% of the Democrats voted Yes on both bills.
    63% of the Republicans voted No on both.
    Of course, most of them got tobacco money and voted NO, a few got money and voted Yes.
    (I didn’t check if that was the last tobacco money they got. :-))
    However, of the 41 GOP Senate(14)+Assembly(27) members,:
    SB SB # X = No vote recorded
    277 7
    Y Y 2
    N* Y 4
    Y N 2
    N* N 26
    Y X 0
    N* X 7

    So, that’s 37 of 41 or 90% GOP who voted No on strengthening vaccination requirements.
    The corresponding # Yes from Dems was (59+5+2)=66/74 = 89% Yes.
    unlike tobacco $, I couldn’t easily find anti-vaxx money … but at least in CA, the *legislators* had already diverged strongly by 2015.

  9. Andrew, you should do a critical analysis of an idea you assume is NOT junk science. Its interesting how people can recognize the NHST issues but appear to mentally recoil from considering the implications (that the literature is ~99.99% junk science). I definitely did that for a few years before finally accepting the reality.

    A good heuristic is that the more emotional people feel about a topic, the crappier the evidence.

    • You seem quite “emotional” about this topic, and certainly so do the vast majority of people who believe there’s evidence (as apparently do you) that vaccines are ineffective or cause harm. How’s that heuristic working now?

      • “Ineffective” and “causing harm” are binary absolutist statements, just like ‘vaccine denial’, but we all know what happens to those who dichotomize continuum ’round here :-))

        Jokes aside, by now, many side effects have been well-documented.
        Myocarditis:
        https://med.stanford.edu/news/all-news/2025/12/myocarditis-vaccine-covid.html

        Chronic fatigue:
        https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10674626/

        The one below basically admits we already know there may be issues with mrna tech, so we need to pay attention to future vaccines:
        https://www.cam.ac.uk/research/news/researchers-redesign-future-mrna-therapeutics-to-prevent-potentially-harmful-immune-responses

        DNA to mRNA and vice versa:
        https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35723296/

        Meanwhile on PBS:
        https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1S74vYWKee8
        :-)))

        Remember when ‘herd immunity’ was used as an excuse to mandate everyone gets vaccinated while virologists were screaming that there was no such thing as sterilization (you won’t protect your old grandma by vaccinating your children)?

        Here’s a good talk on flu pandemic. At min 47. he mentions that 60% of people in challenge trials still shed virus with the new vaccine:
        https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E6VGLiBNoFg&t=3302s

        • Those mRNA trials didn’t even take the most basic precautions like regular testing and exit polling. The blinding was obviously compromised due to the acute reactions to the vaccines.

          The list of problems does not stop there, but that’s sufficient to reject those trials already. This is not real science, but people don’t care. Their standards have been lowered via decades of marketing/propaganda so they will settle for junk.

          Also, Joshua won’t critically read any papers (he relies on choosing which expert to trust), but Andrew does have the expertise to do so if he took the time.

        • Anoneuoid —

          This is garbage time, but I’ll write one comment to correct one thing because you keep making the same error over and over. I’ve corrected it before, and maybe repeating it again won’t get you to update your priors, but here goes.

          “he relies on choosing which expert to trust”

          That’s your framing, but it’s not my process.

          I don’t “trust” “experts” or choose among them based on some perceived “authority.” I skim papers, look at abstracts and conclusions, follow up on key claims, look for conflicting results, and read critiques from people with different views. When I read expert commentary, I’m looking at the reasoning, not sorting people by status. And I try to stay aware of my own limits instead of pretending I can evaluate every technical detail. I try to evaluate probabilities, and while “authority” is one element that feeds into the equation, it’s never dispositive and always conditional and informed by context (including the possibility of “group speak”).

          Your mistake is collapsing that into a two‑category model (which echoes the recent thread about forcing dichotomies onto things that exist on continuous scales): either someone has total technical mastery, or they’re “trusting experts.” That’s a false dichotomy. And ironically, it mirrors back into your own process, where you treat your ability to dig into technical details as if it lifts you above the basic cognitive biases you think everyone else fails to account for. The result is that your technical skills become a shield, one that keeps you from noticing when your conclusions reflect biases that are obvious to other readers here.

          And this seems to be why you don’t update your priors. When I tell you directly that your assumptions about my process are wrong, all you read is “trusting experts.” So nothing I say about my reasoning counts as evidence about my reasoning. You’ve built a filter that keeps you from revising the story you’ve already settled on.

          Repeating that framing doesn’t make it right.

        • Navigator –

          Just to be clear, in my response to Anoneuoid, I wasn’t making any categorical claim about vaccines being “perfectly safe or perfectly effective,” and I wasn’t denying the existence of documented side effects. My point was about how people reason under uncertainty, and how quickly the discussion gets flattened into binaries. I was trying to point out how Anoneuoid was relying on a simplistic narrative and selective application.

          Your links, which are obviously cherry‑picked, are part of the overall picture, but they don’t really speak to the point I was making. Responding to me as if I’d taken an absolutist position ends up reproducing the same dichotomizing you talked about above.

    • Navigator –

      Not the place to go down this rabbit hole. I’ll just give a top level response.

      Part of my point was that these evaluations AREN’T binary, but nonetheless there are many people who are “emotionally” invested in a categorical belief that despite the complicated evidence, vaccines are ineffective or harmful. Somehow, methinks, Anoneuoid wasn’t thinking of those “people” as he was looking down upon his “emotional” inferiors.

      And I do remember when “herd immunity” was the reason why the Great Barrington Declaration folks said we should just let it rip, and how those same MAHA- and vaccine-skeptic associated nutbars that control our public health systems declared that we’d reached “herd-immunity” in the Spring of 2020

  10. You write:
    > It’s interesting that Krugman says that “the relationship between quack medicine and right-wing extremism has a long history.” My impression is that,
    > before very recently, there was no correlation between political ideology and belief in quack medicine.

    I think Krugman is right. The NSDAP was very much in favour of quack medicine and even changed legislation in Germany to give it legal status. So there still is the profession of ‘Heilpraktiker’ which is just a cute name for a quack.

  11. Yes a lot of it is right wing tied. But there is an issue i the US where we assume homogeneity within the right and left. This simply is not the case. For example, not all highly religious or moderately religious people are right wing. Even within Christianity there are big differences on specific issues. And if you are really Catholic you believe that abortion is wrong and that the death penalty is wrong. You have the JD Vance version of hate the stranger/the “West” should prevail and then you have the version that says we should feed the hungry, love our neighbors and visit prisoners.

    I would say that mainstream liberals believe in regulation for health and safety and believe in expertise. The right tends to be anti-government and for the free market. So if I were marketing some kind of quack belief that is where I would go. And of course once I start making money I would prefer a government that doesn’t look at if I’m committing fraud and that won’t tax me too much.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *