We’ve been hearing a lot about wasteful public spending, so this story seems relevant:
Benjamin E. Sasse, former president of the University of Florida, spent unjustified amounts of money on university salaries, events, and contracts, with little to show for the expenses, according to a report the state’s auditor general released Tuesday.
The university failed to show how any of the expenses detailed in the report benefited the university . . .
Sasse’s office spent $14.8 million during the year he was in office, about 72 percent more than his predecessor did the year before.
Among the top payments was a $6.4-million contract with McKinsey & Company, a consulting firm meant to help the university chart a path forward. Neither university records nor employees could show the contract’s benefits to the auditor general’s office, according to the report. . . .
During his short 17-month tenure, Sasse hired 24 employees who held 38 different administrative positions. Several of those employees worked remotely, incurring large reimbursements for travel to the university.
Fourteen of those positions didn’t include job descriptions . . .
One of Sasse’s remote hires was Penny Schwinn, the university’s first vice president for PK-12 and pre-bachelor’s programs, who served less than a year in her position. She earned a salary of $367,500 and incurred about $17,500 in expenses that were paid for by the university, primarily for work travel, according to records The Chronicle obtained via an open-records request.
And here’s the kicker:
Schwinn has since been nominated by President Trump to serve as deputy secretary in the U.S. Department of Education.
There’s more:
The report says the university didn’t “document the reasonableness” of maintaining Sasse’s more than $1-million salary after he stepped down from the presidency in July 2024. He now serves as a part-time professor and an adviser to the university’s trustees. . . . Sasse’s responsibilities in his adviser position “appear to be significantly less in scope” than those of the president, according to the auditor’s report, and “the public purpose of such a salary is not readily apparent.”
And this sleazy bit:
The university . . . noted that about 80 percent of the salary comes from non-state funds, in accordance with state law that caps presidential salaries.
Hey, assholes: Money is fungible. That’s a million bucks that otherwise could’ve gone for university operations.
More fun:
Sasse also spent about $376,000 on flights chartered through the University Athletic Association. The average trip cost $16,820 . . . Other expenses include an hour-long holiday party featuring hot chocolate, cider, peppermint chocolates, and cookies that cost $62,650; a two-hour holiday party for university employees that cost $169,755; and an invitation-only football tailgate that cost about $46,000.
Jeez . . . for $62,650 you think they could’ve afforded some booze . . .
The news article points to Sasse’s post here in defense of . . . actually I’m not sure what he’s defending. As befits his position of retired politician, he spews a lot of platitudes: “fiscal stewardship . . . hardworking taxpayers . . . the salt-of-the-earth people . . . the AI revolution . . . status-quo bureaucracies . . . lifelong learning . . . the first time in human histories . . . an unprecedented consortium . . . brought to fruition . . . disruptive . . . top talent . . .” He calls people “folks.”
The funniest part is when he writes, “Any $9 billion enterprise should always be finding ways to tighten its belt.”
In all those 1700 words, he never said anything about the million dollars he’s getting for his current mini-job, the $6.4 million to the consulting firm that yielded no benefits, the $62,650 party, the $376,000 in flights, or the 72% increase in spending. If that’s belt-tightening, I’d hate to see what happens when the guy goes wild and lets loose!
On the plus side, the University of Florida is now looking for a new president. I heard this guy is available?
Are all those open science and transparency people also talking about openness and transparency regarding funding, grants, where the money regarding research is specifically used for, who is funding what, etc.
Perhaps that might be useful. Perhaps they can start themselves: does anyone know whether a center of open science CEO have made transparent what they make a year? Or does anyone know whether such an organization clearly and transparently provides information about who gives them money to do what they do? And what about all those helpful organizations like the APA, APS, etc.? Do they provide some financial overview each year in a clear manner?
Maybe there can be a new open science badge (with a $-sign or something like that), where the specific information about grant money and expenses for certain studies and subsequent papers is depicted somewhere in the paper.
Was that meant to be a defense of, or response to, Sasse’s actions? If so, I find it weak (close to valueless) and off-point. Lots of contracted work – almost all – has padded numbers and contains some “waste.” Purely private for-profit firms as well. I’ve worked mostly in the private sector and seen plenty of waste. But I think the higher you rise in the hierarchy, the more important it is to be transparent and accountable, and the President of a major university system certainly qualifies. Like so much of the current administration’s response to criticism, your statement amounts to “don’t point your finger at me, I’m just doing what everyone else does.” There are two big problems I have with that stance: first, the level of abuse is not comparable and you haven’t actually provided evidence of what others are doing. Second, and more important, the goal should be to do better, not justify bad actions because others behave badly. The same issues arise with the much overlooked lifting of enforcement of rules against company bribes of foreign officials. The justification given is that American companies need to be able to compete with foreign companies on a level playing field, and they use bribes. What an admirable race to the bottom. Drain the swamps indeed.
“Mommy, they did it first/too” has unfortunately become the fundamental principle of much political discourse.
Quote from above: “Was that meant to be a defense of, or response to, Sasse’s actions?”
I don’t know who Sasse is. I also don’t defend or respond to that particular situation or person.
I just focused on the spending money and connected it to the transparency stuff and wondered whether there could, and should, be much more transparency concerning those things in (psychological) science.
I was wondering whether all the recent talk about open science and transparency also mentions being open and transparent about funding and where exactly the money is being spend on, etc.
> I don’t know who Sasse is. I also don’t defend or respond to that particular situation or person.
So Dale was correct to say that you were off-point, since whatever you were saying had nothing to do with the original post.
Anyway, if you are interested in how grant funds are managed, there are extensive public reporting requirements for any grant. For example, here are the requirements for the NIH:
https://grants.nih.gov/grants-process/post-award-monitoring-and-reporting/reporting-requirements
And those for the NSF:
https://www.nsf.gov/awards/report-your-outcomes
Those requirements apply to all federal grants, not just those in the psychological sciences.
Quote from above: “So Dale was correct to say that you were off-point, since whatever you were saying had nothing to do with the original post.”
I don’t know if Dale was correct or not. The title of the blog post is “speaking of government waste…” and the content of the blog post includes money and how it was used. I connected money and spending in academia/science with the whole openness and transparency stuff. I don’t see what’s so “off-point” about that.
Regardless, thank you for the links and information. Following those links, it’s pretty unclear to me, but it seems that your links are about funders receiving information from researchers how their money has been spent. If this is correct, and in light of the openness stuff, I would like this information to be more available to members of the general public and other researchers, not necessarily merely the funders. I would also like when this information is very specific, I would like to know how much a CEO of some center or society gets payed, and who provides all the funding, and how much money is spent in free lunches, etc. etc.
More generally and importantly, I wonder whether there should be some more transparency concerning those things in light of several problematic issues in academia/science.
It’s easy to find out who Sasse is. The second sentence of the post (the beginning of the quote) reads, “Benjamin E. Sasse, former president of the University of Florida,. . .”
I counted eight uses of the name Sasse in the post.
Yes, I read the name Sasse in the post. It’s just that I don’t know, or care, who he is exactly or what he does specifically in this case. I am more focused on the general topic of waste, money in science/academia, etc. I just skip through the particular name and function and more details that are not necessarily important in that light. For instance, I also don’t know or read or remember how he specifically spent money even though I think I remember certain details of that being mentioned in the blog post as well. I just skip trough those details as well, as they are not very important concerning what I like to further discuss.
When reading these posts I tend to focus on what I find most interesting, and use that as jumping off point to discuss something. In this case that was the money aspect of present-day academia and the connection to transparency and openness. Certain details like names, functions, details about how exactly money was spent don’t matter much sometimes I reason.
Anon
Well that explains why I often find your posts off topic – and sometimes bewilderingly so. It is not that waste in academia is unimportant, it is just that it seemed tenuously related to the post.
From the blog post: “Benjamin E. Sasse, former president of the University of Florida, spent unjustified amounts of money on university salaries, events, and contracts, with little to show for the expenses, according to a report the state’s auditor general released Tuesday.”
I honestly don’t see how me talking about wasting money in academia and connecting this to transparency is strange or off topic or whatever.
But perhaps it’s a matter of perspective or it’s subjective. I honestly don’t get it. But I hope it’s okay for me to wrote what I wrote.
Quote from above: “I honestly don’t see how me talking about wasting money in academia and connecting this to transparency is strange or off topic or whatever.”
Wait, could it be that the connecting something (wasting money in academia) to a possibly relevant other thing (transparency) that may or may not be something that someone else connects to the first thing is what causes the possible confusion or whatever word is most appropriate here? If that’s the case, then I can perhaps understand the reactions.
I think I tend to connect things to each other maybe a bit more than other people might do. I like to be useful and connect appropriate things to each other though, although that may sometimes be a matter of perspective and subjectivity as well I reason.
I recently finished writing a manuscript in which I connect and combine questionable and unethical research practices and behavior, (successful) psychopathy, and Cleckley’s 1941/1988 book about psychopathy titled “The Mask of Sanity”. If you may be flabbergasted concerning me connecting certain things here, I fear that manuscript might be a whole new level of possible flabberastedness. Should you be interested you can find it on SSRN with the title “Why psychopathy might be present and prosperous in present-day psychological science”.
Just like me commenting here, I hope that manuscript might be useful in some way, shape, or form…
Funny thing is, I frequently thought that Sasse showed more coherence in his political thought than many of his colleagues (even though I rarely agreed with him). Again, for me at least, it shows that there are fairly distinct domains of “integrity.”
I’m not sure if any of this is a surprise to people, but it’s not a surprise to me. Universities are best thought of as capitalist hedge funds whose purpose is to fund salaries of the top 50-100 bureaucrats (the “profit”). They teach courses to qualify for tax breaks. To socially aggrandize these top 100 bureaucrats there are a whole host of second tier bureaucrats who can be classified in terms of David Graeber’s taxonomy from his book “Bullshit Jobs”… Let’s see if I can remember off the top of my head: goons, box tickers, flunkies, duct tapers, and taskmasters…
Higher Ed administration has been an exceedingly fast growing “industry”. I had a little trouble web searching for a graph that is up to date but stuff from the 2010-2015 era is pretty widespread, showing that administration has grown faster than student body by far, and that hourly adjuncts are replacing full professors, with results like this:
https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2017/sep/28/adjunct-professors-homeless-sex-work-academia-poverty
Universities are shameful, and Columbia University did particularly poorly in the recent student protests.
It’s time to recognize that however good your favorite few dedicated professors are, it’s almost certain that they are a trivial fraction of what any large University does.
I certainly share your critique of higher education. But I do think you overstate the case – I don’t think dedicated professors are “a trivial fraction of what any large University does.” I do think that the larger the institution, the smaller the fraction of its budget and activities involve “dedicated professors” (based on 50 years of teaching at around 15 universities of various sizes). I personally think a total revamp of higher education is in order – but it requires a good deal of discourse and careful consideration of the multiple objectives served by these institutions. What has happened at the University of Florida is not an example of that. We didn’t get discourse about many things that are worthy of critique, what we got was a power play. Much like the vision of democracy we are seeing on an hourly basis these days.
Dale, perhaps we have a different view of what constitutes the “dedicated” professor. In my experience they constitute around 10-15% of professors. And professors constitute like 30% of employees, so this group constitutes single digits percentages of what Universities have on staff. And the box tickers and taskmasters keep them occupied 50% of the time with faculty meetings and updating their animal use protocols and meeting with flunkeys of Deans and things that as a whole perhaps 1-5% of all activity at a university rises to the ideal of quality education and research.
Of course, there’s plenty of other teaching just absolutely wrong stuff, like how to set up two tailed t tests to determine if the difference in priming produces a “real effect” in walking speed or whatever. I exclude the teaching of crap science from my catalog of “dedicated” faculty activity.
Anyone who wants to hear what a truly dedicated researcher experienced can read about Katalin Kariko and think about how many others werent neurodiverse enough to put up with all that crap and just bugged out.
If I look at most of the colleagues I’ve had over the years, I might not be far off from the percentages you cite. So, in a sense, I agree with you. But I also know that my vision of dedication (which I believe I exhibit) is different than others, and that student perceptions (and perhaps employer perceptions) don’t necessarily align with my own. In other words, teaching methodologies and beliefs are extremely variable, and while I believe in my own I recognize that these are not universally shared. Much like all democratic processes, things are messy and not as clear as you might like.
I have always found the enormous “box-checking” mentality offensive. I hate rubrics, at least any rubric that is detailed, yet most of higher education uses them. The trend is towards ever more granular and “measurable” rubrics for everything from class participation through final grades. I personally find this trend at odds with the purpose of education – but I know this is a view not widely shared. Does this mean I am “dedicated” and the rubric-followers are not? I’m not prepared to assert that. So, I might agree that “perhaps 1-5% of all activity at a university rises to the ideal of quality education and research,” but I suspect the definition of that 1-5% varies a lot across individuals. So, we are left with a much grayer picture than you suggest.
Even so Dale, perhaps we can approximate this diversity of opinion as if it were 3-4 schools of thought treated as approximately no overlapping. And let’s take a median kind of number like 3% so multiply that by 3-4 no overlapping sets and you’re still talking 9-12% of university activity is what we think of as quality education to at least one group of people. And then we could go into salary disparity. How much of that quality is actually provided by the adjuncts who are doing it out of love more than money? Even if 12% of the people are within our extended set, it could still be 3-5% of the money.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Katalin_Karik%C3%B3
Yes, vaccines where everyone gets infected anyway. Also, mortality comparisons during the RCTs show 15% higher all-cause mortality in the vaccinated. Then the epidemiological data is confounded by 3-10x higher all-cause mortality in unvaccinated (because most terminally ill people fall in that group).
Btw,100% of published papers on the topic agree with the above. There are none that disagree, only ones that ignore the inconvenient information and /or play games with definitions like “death due to covid”.
Fisher, R N (1958). “The Nature of Probability”. Centennial Review. 2: 261–274. https://www.york.ac.uk/depts/maths/histstat/fisher272.pdf
Just want to say again that this level of misinformation is really, really, scary. This is civilization and even species destroying stuff. I won’t be responding to anything else in this thread.
Daniel
Perhaps just one more go around. By your estimates on the order of 90% of university spending and activity is not needed for quality education. I think that is too high. Let me give 2 examples. First, many universities have an administrative position (sometimes more than one) designated as a Chief Diversity Officer. I personally think they accomplish little and cause a number of wasteful things (like checkboxed reports on diversity activities). So, I would consider them not essential to quality education. But if you give me a choice between no such administrative office or the existing one, I’m not sure what I’d say. Just eliminating these positions strikes me as tantamount to saying either that there is no problem or that the problem cannot be addressed. Now I’m sure that you and I could find some agreement on a better policy for increasing the diversity of students and faculty (assuming that is a goal), but somehow the systems we have came up with such positions. Change is hard – unless you have a dictator (and then hope they have the right objectives).
2nd example: many administrative positions are Deans or Directors, and in larger schools, perhaps numerous Associate or Assistant such positions. I’ve actually directed several MBA programs and I’ve served as Chair of a department (all small ones). I have never thought of myself as an administrator, nor do I like much of that work. But one thing I realized is that there needs to be such a person if anything is to get done. I found my colleagues willing to express opinions and ideas, but somehow they always looked to me in order to get anything accomplished. It was not because I was good at it – it was because it was necessary to have someone “in charge” if anything was to get done. I’m not willing to speculate on how many administrative positions are like that, but I certainly think a significant portion are.
I think these types of things are relevant to any discussion of “waste” in any organization or industry. It is easy to pick things that look like waste but harder to find ways to eliminate it without denying the reason why it existed to begin with. I’m perfectly willing to say that waste can accumulate to such a point that drastic action is needed (and quite possibly universities are at that point). But I care a lot about how drastic action is taken. I don’t want an authoritarian response, regardless of what its stated goals are. I want a more deliberative and inclusive (I’m purposely choosing that maligned word) process. That would represent something that truly separates the human species from most other animals (and machines).
Dale –
But if you give me a choice between no such administrative office or the existing one, I’m not sure what I’d say. Just eliminating these positions strikes me as tantamount to saying either that there is no problem or that the problem cannot be addressed. Now I’m sure that you and I could find some agreement on a better policy for increasing the diversity of students and faculty (assuming that is a goal), but somehow the systems we have came up with such positions. Change is hard – unless you have a dictator (and then hope they have the right objectives).
Three cheers for non-binary thinking. It’s often true that even if something works poorly you can’t necessarily infer that we’re better off without it. That case has to be made, in the specified context of what it is that would be better.
Dale –
I think these types of things are relevant to any discussion of “waste” in any organization or industry. It is easy to pick things that look like waste but harder to find ways to eliminate it without denying the reason why it existed to begin
Three more cheers (hip, hip, hooray?). This reminds me of DOGE, where it’s axiomatic that cutting services they don’t like equals eliminating “waste or fraud.”
Dale, the “need” for such hierarchical positions is because of the structure of universities and other institutions as hierarchical organizations with specific goals, primary among which are the benefits that accrue to the top few.
Earning millions of dollars in salaries for doing not much isn’t a bug it’s an essential feature of the way these organizations work. Hard working young researchers bust their asses writing 15 grant proposals a year to get 1 that pays 65% overhead which gets put into a pot that is used to pay for golf games and fancy dinners and wine and dine the next generation of young researchers who will bust their asses writing grants to get yet more 65% overheads.
Overheads also go to building new facilities and then wining and dining donors to get them to buy the names of buildings and endowed chairs and things and aggrandize themselves. It’s very rarely any donor provides funds for some poor grad student actually discovering how liver damage happens or whatever.
Why can’t a department have a meeting and designate Sally as the person who will speak for the department with respect to diversity or curriculum development, or whatever, and have a budget associated with the task, and have help from administrative staff etc? And for each task they are spread among the faculty with real power and nontrivial budgets?
Because every time Sally decides something, the dept head has to sign off on it because the top people *want* hierarchy so there is no power sharing. Yes they will do this in a token way sometimes, where someone gets $5000 budget or whatever, but wielding real money is always a matter of some head of some department or Dean of some sort.
In addition, dumping all the administration on a smaller group of administrators gives the lower status profs who do all the grant writing and actually bring in all the money more time to do that grant writing. And above all, these organizations exist to capture those grant overheads and a portion of the grant directs as well.
Mouse costs come from grant direct funds but go to the university husbandry staff. Time on the HPC cluster, similar, use of specialty biochemical sequencing cores… Salaries of professors are paid 50% out of grant direct costs (at med schools I’m familiar with). Grant directs pay for grad student positions, etc. in every case the organization extracts a cut either of funds, or of credit and thereby ability to gather future funds.
The whole system is best thought of as an exploitative factory of prestige and grant rents that happens to teach some classes for the tax benefits.
Failure to acknowledge that is what universities are leads to all sorts of wrongheaded thinking. Like ramping up funding for bankruptcy ineligible student loans that can only be spent on tuition, and so the Ricardian rent goes exclusively to universities, especially when universities ramp up attendance while allowing quality to decline.
Quote from above: “Failure to acknowledge that is what universities are leads to all sorts of wrongheaded thinking.”
Would talking and writing about “publish or perish” and stop there be one of the things that may contribute to wrongheaded thinking?
I keep wondering about this because if it’s essentially largely about the money, it might be more accurate and useful to talk and write about “passing the hat or perish”, or “funded or faded”, or “financed or finished”, or “backed or begone”, or “subsidized or subsided”.
I was curious about what Anoneuoid said so I did a quick search and found this summary of RCTs https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10402862/ and this https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2024.12.15.24319058v1 (not about an RCT, it’s a cohort study that includes all adults in Norway), at which point I stopped looking. You can safely ignore the claim that all randomized controlled trials of COVID vaccines find increased all-cause mortality, or that there is good evidence that the vaccines increase all-cause mortality.
Ha, thank you for the book title. I looked it up, and you had the 5 types of useless jobs correct if I am understanding the wikipedia page correctly.
I wonder whether you could roughly place that on academia, and see where certain jobs fit in. Maybe “goons” are the researchers who use questionable research practices and receive grants which the university gets a part of and can spend on overhead costs and free lunches or whatever. And “duct tapers” are the researchers replicating the work of the “goons” and wasting even more money, or even asking for replication government money, instead of actually preventing sub-optimal research to be produced.
“Flunkies” could be certain media, and students, who are not aware of the many possible problematic issues with the “goons” research but let those researchers talk about their research a lot, and might even applaud them after a lecture so they feel important and competent. “Taskmasters” might be certain parts of administration that makes professors and teaching staff fill out form after form, and keeps track of evaluations, etc. And “box tickers” might be some sort of committee that oversees al this, but does nothing to improve matters.
Anyway, thanks for the book title.
Goons are a mix of lawyers, deans, department heads, and lobbyists.
Flunkies are a mix of Deans, vice deans, administrative assistants to development office, associate dean for student entertainment and soforth.
Box tickers are doing various kinds of compliance reports and low level computer security audits and things.
Taskmasters are busy creating stuff for box tickers to do, and calling for meetings to discuss policies for new kinds of box ticking.
Duct tapers are inputting data from the useful budgeting software into the useless parallel budgeting software purchased because a high level admin has a friend who is CEO of the company, or fixing the internal network firewalls because they’ve not converted to IPv6 and have overlapping NAT domains or installing software into virtual machines to run old hardware because the rent seekers at the company that makes the hardware charge $60,000 for upgrades or whatever.
There is a problem with the book “Bullshit jobs.” I agree with much of it, and I think it is important to note that it is not specific to higher education but instead talks about all sorts of employment. These types of critiques are valuable. They are eye-opening and necessary. But recognize that they are exactly the kind of eye-opening stuff that DOGE is using. The problem with adopting that view of the world is that it invites disruption according to a specific view of the world – one that is not universally shared. So, if you get enough power you can enact your disruptions and this seems like a good thing since most of what people are currently doing is “bullshit jobs.” If I different group gets power, then a different set of jobs gets labeled that way.
What I want to see is discourse about what is necessary or desirable and for what objectives – and discourse rather than edicts. “Bullshit jobs” is a necessary component since it shakes our inertia and forces us to face questions about things we have been far too complacent about. But I think when we adopt that view (such as ending up with 1-5% of professors dedicated to real learning, or a small percent of government employees doing real work) we skip the step of discourse and impose a singular view of the world. Then it becomes just a matter of who has the power to enact their view.
Dale, far too little discussion about what we value in society. I totally agree with that. As an anthropologists Graeber didn’t want to impose his own value too highly, so he decided his category of bullshit jobs would be ones that the worker themself couldn’t even justify. Box tickers for example who compile enormous reports that no one ever reads. Duct tapers who received print outs of pages of numbers and spend all day typing them into spreadsheets instead of someone getting the original computer files with the numbers… Etc etc
When it comes to DOGE they may be superficially using the idea of bullshit jobs, but this is a transparent cover story. The people they’re firing are some of the most purposeful and impactful. USAID saves millions of lives a year. The NOAA weather reports are used by billions of people from everything from scheduling sports games to planting and harvesting to giving the red flag warnings that allowed me to be ready to evacuate when the Altadena fires hit burning 10,000 structures and costing tens or hundreds of billions in damages.
To DOGE a thing is a waste if it isn’t purely lining the pockets of the rentier class, providing services is considered waste. The opposite of the Bullshit Jobs critique.
USAID is effectively an arm of the CIA. The people who “benefit” from it are just being made dependents of us. Real foreign aid would be making them independent of us (e.g. equipment and methods to treat their own AIDS epidemics and develop new treatments on their own instead of us simply doing it for them).
This article is pro-USAID but even it acknowledges the close connection so it suffices to demonstrate the point:
“In my twenties, when I told people that my father had worked for U.S.A.I.D., the inevitable knowing response was “You mean the C.I.A.”
The proximity between the two agencies was hard to deny. In the sixties, America often disbursed aid as “credits” to foreign governments, which in turn supplied the equivalent amount of local currency to the U.S. Embassy. The funds were apportioned by the “country intelligence team”—which invariably included the C.I.A. station chief….”
https://www.newyorker.com/news/the-lede/growing-up-usaid
Anonymous: yeah, good to know. Wouldn’t surprise me at all. And I agree with your idea of true foreign aid being that which makes the country able to handle its own issues.
USAID apparently also funds all sorts of domestic farm subsidies and things like that. Effectively though it’s portion of the budget is negligible, you could get rid of it entirely and provide all its services somehow “free” by magic wands and still just barely affect the third decimal place of the US budget
https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2025/02/06/what-the-data-says-about-us-foreign-aid/
I have long been critical of USAID, which to a significant degree was an arm of US “soft power” foreign policy.
That said, they provided critical support for untold numbers of people. Binary thinking is sub-optimal.
“USAID is effectively an arm of the CIA. The people who “benefit” from it are just being made dependents of us.”
Get real. The single biggest recipient of USAID funding for the past two years has been Ukraine. Donald Trump despises Ukraine (or at least acts like he does) and wants Russia to win (or at least acts like he does) so perhaps it is not surprising that he hates USAID.
I wouldn’t try to defend everything USAID does but to say it’s just a front for the CIA is false. And ridiculous.
Millions of people are indeed dependent on US aid. Some of those people will now die, many others will be miserable, or more miserable than they were. Yay, let’s all celebrate the suffering people and the dying people, because they will no longer be dependent on us. Isn’t that great?
I don’t know enough to gauge how much US AID and the CIA overlap, though I would expect they are not completely separate nor can I believe they are tightly integrated – as Joshua says, it isn’t binary. But if you believe they are largely one and the same, then it makes it even stranger that Trump wants them gone. His purported complaint is that they are doing things contrary to our national interest – unless he also thinks the CIA is working contrary to our national interest. I suppose that might be the case (he has complained about the CIA in the past), but then he is saying that virtually no government agency is working to promote US interests. As soon as I write that, I realize this might be the case. How can so many people be wrong and only one person be right? (I guess I suffer from Trump derangement syndrome)
Phil,
“I wouldn’t try to defend everything USAID does but to say it’s just a front for the CIA is false. And ridiculous.”
It’s only a slight exaggeration to say this. Read the quote.
Here’s another example. USAID’s HIV program in Cuba tried to foment a rebellion instead of giving people HIV drugs.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/morning-mix/wp/2014/08/04/report-u-s-aid-used-hiv-program-in-cuba-to-foment-rebellion/
If I was president I would tell Congress to pass a law to make USAID real foreign aid, instead of what it is currently. Most of the dying people are in the HIV program, it is unfortunate (though HIV is not instant death, they have a couple of months to find alternative treatments). Trump probably thinks it is too left-wing, instead of too right-wing.
Anonymous –
Here’s another example. USAID’s HIV program in Cuba
It’s one example (Cuba). And it’s one part of that one example (they conducted more than just political activities).
This really isn’t that complicated.
Pedantry doesn’t score you any points, Joshua. Do I need to rephrase it as “CIA-like activities and strong ties to the CIA”? USAID’s purpose is to use foreign aid to make others dependent on us and advance what the US government thinks is its interest. This is consistent with USAID providing some amount of help. It really isn’t that complicated, like you said.
If I wrote a book going over the whole sordid record, you would just say “it’s a small part of it” again. Such books have been written before, by the way, e.g. “Killing Hope”.
I even said how to fix it in my first comment. Not sure what else you want.
Professors have, in turn (as a group), acted shamefully with regard to rampant “adjunctification” to protect their niche in the social hierarchy.
That I totally agree with. I’ve seen various estimates, but I believe the tenure track faculty is at most 20% of the professor workforce. The disparity in earnings is striking, and tenure track faculty have mostly been silent about the stark realities.
Some relevant data here: https://www.aaup.org/article/data-snapshot-tenure-and-contingency-us-higher-education
Why hasn’t Sasse been charged with fraud? That is, has he done anything that could get reprimanded by an ethics board? Could he be charged for, say, stealing from a public university for his increase in salary? If so, why hasn’t he? The answer — this is just speculation — is that Sasse has just taken advantage of a broken system.
He raised his salary to a $1 million/year because he could, without recrimination. He hired many people (no doubt his friends and family) because he could. As I repeatedly point out to people who warn me about the dangers of Trump, if a system allows this much damage from one person, then the system is broken.
In other words, it should be assumed that the worst person will eventually hold the most powerful position.
Quote from above: “In other words, it should be assumed that the worst person will eventually hold the most powerful position.”
I think I think it’s better to say ‘In other words, it should be assumed that the worst person might eventually hold the most powerful position.”
Regardless, I have been thinking about how one person, or few collaborating people, might hold a possibly indesirable powerful position by talking about collaboration and stuff like that but can direct things by making sure people can only choose between a few options or stuff like that.
The point is that it might then look like someone, or a few collaborating people, might not have too much power and influence in things because their few options are then voted for by lost of people so it seems “democratic” and “the whole group decided”, etc.
Sam:
I imagine that Sasse could be charged with some sort of misuse of funds, but the people would make that decision are themselves political employees.
Beyond that, it does seem that white-collar offenses are rarely prosecuted. A few years back we had a Columbia professor was, according to a news report, the subject of “a grueling investigation into a quarter-million dollars of spending that Columbia auditors said was insufficiently documented, misappropriated or outright fabricated.” It says that he paid back $13,000 . . . and that was it! I have no idea what happened to the other $228,364. And he’s still a professor at Columbia! Also this guy.
+1
Unless you think that the cookie party etc never happened, how would it be fraud?
However, I can say that at CUNY funding for parties has to come from sources like auxiliary enterprises or a small fund for “college events” which mainly is used for commencement. Similarly, no lunch for meetings unless the meeting lasts for at least 90 minutes. No funding for booze ever. But Florida may not have this level of regulation.
Your post reminded me of a paper I came across recently titled “White-collar criminality” by E. H. Sutherland (1940). A quote from that paper:
“The present-day white-collar criminals, who are more suave and deceptive than the “robber barons,” are represented by Krueger, Stavisky, Whitney, Mitchell, Foshay, Insull, the Van Sweringens, Musica-Coster, Fall, Sinclair, and many other merchant princes and captains of finance and industry, and by a host of lesser followers. Their criminality has been demonstrated again and again in the investigations of land offices, railways, insurance, munitions, banking, public utilities, stock exchanges, the oil industry, real estate, reorganization committees, receiverships, bankruptcies, and politics.”
I couldn’t quite fit it into my writing at the time, but I found it interesting to read. If I understood things correctly he may have been the one to come up with the term white-collar criminality.
Yes he is credited with creating that term and using in his the American Sociological Association presidential address in 1939, published in ASR in 1940.
Ah, thanks for the confirmation.
If I understand things correctly, he wrote about some general processes or hypotheses in that paper that could explain both white-collar criminality and lower class criminality. It was remarkable and kind of funny to me that he subsequently seemed to me to focus on learned behavior and the environment (he used some fancy terms “differential association” and “social disorganization” if I understood things correctly but these terms are vague to me) and not so much personality characteristics like psychopathy.
I found that remarkable and funny because it seemed to me that Sutherland dismissed and/or didn’t like psychopathy as an hypothesis concerning, or explanation for, both white-collar and lower class criminality while I was explicitly connecting psychopathy to questionable and unethical research behavior which included scientific fraud, which in turn is perhaps something like, or close to, white-collar criminality.
I also came across a paper about psychopathy that sort of underscored the idea of viewing psychopathy as something that can explain both upper class and lower class unethical behavior, or white-collar criminality and lower class criminality, by noting the historically their has often been made distinctions within psychopathy that can be seen as representing the criminal, unsuccessful psychopath on the one side, and the swindler, successful psychopath on the other side. I think that might fit the idea that psychopathy can be an appropriate concept to explain both white-collar criminality and lower class criminality and I don’t really understand why it seemed to me that Sutherland seemed to dismiss that but I may have not read the paper with enough attention and focus. Regardless, I didn’t want to go the white-collar criminality route concerning questionable and unethical research related behavior.
> he spews a lot of platitudes
That is a truly amazing combination of things. Also wow, Twitter blog posts. I guess the character limit is gone or something
Well it’s interesting that with all the idiotic expenditures that have been exposed in the last month this $14.8M is the special one you single out for attention. :) I agree it’s a disgrace. I’m not making excuses. But you consistently focus your radar gun only on elephants and routinely ignore donkeys. Just another day in the faculty lounge.
This kind of spending is surely rampant in universities nationwide. Universities are just federal dollar mining machines. No one gives a shit if the mining creates a beneficial product, as long as the mining execs can keep hiring their pals and bucking up everyone’s salaries. As others have noted, this hardly reflects well on faculty, who are thrilled to let the ball keep rolling as long as they get thier grants pursue their bunny-humping observation hobby.
Anon:
1. You say that I “consistently focus your radar gun only on elephants and routinely ignore donkeys.” Go tell that to Cass Sunstein (who worked for the Obama administration), go tell that Steven Levitt (who said he thought “would be the greatest president in history”), go tell it to Erik Jones (mentioned in the very last line of the above post; I have no idea what is party affiliation is), go tell it to Brad Bushman (donated multiple times to ActBlue, albeit small-dollar amounts), go tell it to Lawrence Tribe, etc et etc. Most of the time, political affiliation doesn’t come up at all; here’s one of many examples. It makes me so mad that these guys cheat and cheat and then just float off on their golden parachutes.
In any case, yeah, I’ll report these 14.8 million dollar scandals when I see them. As you say, and I agree, it’s a disgrace, whatever is the party affiliation, if any, or the perpetrator. I can’t cover everything, or even most things, so you should feel free to start your own blog sharing other examples. Some of the crime involves both parties, for example Republican president Donald Trump calling off the prosecution of Democratic mayor Eric Adams. I think it’s absolutely horrible that this sort of thing isn’t more of a scandal.
2. Please save this empty statements (“federal dollar mining machines”) and the abuse (“bunny-humping observation”) for twitter or 4chan or whatever. Standards are higher here our comment section. Disagreement is fine, reactions are fine, specific examples are fine, just not this sort of crudeness and empty attacks.
I wade in meekly for a defense of sorts for Sasse. Given the briefness of his tenure (17 months) and the trying-to-turn-a-battleship nature of sprawling university systems, I’m not sure it’s really even possible to evaluate his performance. As an outsider to the university (indeed, an outsider the state when he started) hiring McKinsey might not have produced much of value (and Sasse used to work for them) but trying to get some organization to help him get his arms around an organization that large doesn’t seem like a terrible idea. I wouldn’t have hired McKinsey for this purpose, but the output “we gave Sasse an independent assess$4.6 million doesn’t seem that outlandish for a McKinsey study of a severalment of the University” is the sort of thing that doesn’t require a lot of justification, as long as they did it. They probably spent more than others would have, but if Sasse trusted them, this doesn’t seem an exhorbitant sum for an institution as large as UF.
He really was, I think, trying to change things — note in particular his nascent shakeup at the New College of Florida. And he wasn’t forced out; he surprised everyone by leaving to take care of his wife. I’m perfectly willing to grant that he didn’t spend taxpayer money as if it was his own, and he deserves criticism for this. If he had continued, we could have found out what he would have done in the face of this criticism. As to his current stipend, I think you misinterpret the fungibility of money. The 80 percent raised from outside sources would probably not have gone to the university at all — I think it’s really directed at Sasse personally to partially replace his UF salary.
Finally,as to the increase in party spending compared to his predecessor, I think a lot of that was spent to introduce himself to backers; I think it would have shrunk over time, but I admit this is just a guess on my part.
There is some garbled text within the quotes regarding McKinsey. I tried (and failed) to move some text around. Jut ignore from “$4.6” to “several.” And it should have been $6.4.
Discourse on the blog increasingly gets courser. As in “Hey, assholes: Money is fungible” and “bullshit” appearing 7 times so far. Reminds me of my youth in the Southeast Bronx when reference to bodily functions filled the air. Such linguistic reliance in a statistics blog is indicative of how far we are sinking from reasonable, thought-out views. Am I being hopelessly old fashioned, longing for not what was never existing? Perhaps so.
Paul, when the neighborhood progeny lose their contest spheroids on your domicile’s front greens, do you confiscate it for all eternity?
It’s interesting and, I guess, predictable that the comments are almost entirely about universities and whether insider skimming is the exception or the rule. Of course, that’s a discussion worth having (provided people point to evidence and don’t just spout their prejudices).
What strikes me is that this is another example of the dishonesty of defunding attacks on government that clothe themselves in a crusade against “waste, fraud and abuse”. I have seen no evidence that suggests that anti-government types are more efficient and legit in their dispersal of public funds than pro-government types. Obviously, insofar as ideological interests play a role, the anti’s have an incentive to make government *less* effective. From the example in the OP and the ongoing slash and burn attack of DOGE on the federal government, it seems clear to me that fraud-waste-abuse is just a hook, and the real point is not to spend less money per se but lop off institutional functions conservatives don’t agree with.
A prime example of this is Social Security, which is astonishingly efficient as measured by the ratio of administrative costs to benefits paid. Maybe a little less if you look at the match between intended and actual beneficiaries, but I haven’t seen data that addresses this directly. (The false negatives are particularly hard to tabulate.) Wiping out the components of the system that help intended beneficiaries navigate the system, as Musk is doing, has nothing to do with efficiency. Either it’s random (not to be ruled out), or it’s one of the available targets he has at the moment to shrink the system altogether. Of course, his actions are explained (memed) to his followers as getting rid of that ol’ fraud, waste and abuse.
I 100% agree with your assessment of DOGE. It is transparently an attempt to consolidate power into a monarchial sort of government and has nothing to do with efficiency. If you’re measuring services delivered per dollar if anything it’s crashing that number to the ground.
“During his short 17-month tenure, Sasse hired 24 employees who held 38 different administrative positions. Several of those employees worked remotely, incurring large reimbursements for travel to the university.
Fourteen of those positions didn’t include job descriptions . . .”
There is something really suspicious about this analysis with 38 – 24 = 14. Maybe the 14 positions without job descriptions are secondary roles for the employees.
“$6.4 million to the consulting firm that yielded no benefits”
Shouldn’t we skeptical of a hostile investigation concluding no benefits? What would have been considered a benefit?
Static:
When I read that sentence, I assumed that some of the 38 people had multiple positions from some combination of rapid promotion, restructuring, and people moving from one job title to another. Some more detail is here. UF is a public institution so I assume the audit report will become public at some time.
static, there is nothing facially fishy about the employee numbers:
24 hired employees. 24 job descriptions.14 more admin jobs also filled by some of the hired 24.
24 + 14 = 38 different positions.
Sasse was President of the University of Florida, Gainsville campus which is only a part of the whole state university system. Maybe a lot of what he was trying to do was foolish, I don’t know. Conservative Republicans can spend just as much money on useless things as Liberal Democrats do and this is true whether they are in Congress or the private sector.
The bigger issue of most everyone other than the faculty (perhaps), is how the various sports teams will do and is the University of Florida raising enough NIL money to pay its “scholar-athletes.”