“Protection from inappropriate influence is a hallmark of scientific integrity” . . . not any more!

This is a funny one. Remember how Google used to have the slogan, “Don’t be evil,” but then they abandoned it? Something similar seems to have happened with the U.S. Census Bureau.

Dale Lehman pointed me to the story:

I’m sure this is not news to you. But I don’t think the usual lag is appropriate given the seriousness of this.

From the linked item, by economist Justin Wolfers:

“Protection from inappropriate influence is a hallmark of scientific integrity.” That line governed the Census Bureau and then the White House quietly disappeared it. . . .

Three weeks ago, I would have told you that the American government couldn’t suppress economic data like this. But under the new rules that the administration just put forward, the White House can direct its political operatives to kill uncomfortable numbers. . . .

Three weeks ago the United States had a policy that protected the free flow of scientific information and barred political meddling in how Census Bureau findings are presented. Today, it doesn’t.

To be clear: I’m not (yet) saying that our government is cooking the statistical books. Instead, I’m saying that it took the necessary steps to make that legal, and possible. In recent weeks, the Trump administration quietly rewrote the rules that kept political interference out of our economic statistics. And almost nobody noticed.

I didn’t notice either! Contra Lehman’s assumption, this was news to me. I guess that’s how news spreads now: Wolfers posts this on his blog, Lehman sees it and emails the link to me, I post it here and you see it, etc. Sometimes Tyler Cowen or Alex Tabarrok notices items from this blog and they post it on Marginal Revolution. Or maybe Krugman will post on it. The New York Times or Wall Street Journal might cover it too.

What I kind of wonder is how Wolfers heard about it. He’s a user of public data, so it makes sense that he’d be directly interested in the topic. But how did he find out about this obscure announcement? Was he just rooting through the census website one day and noticed something different? Did he see this on some news site? Was it sent to him by an anonymous tipster (I get lots of that sort of email!)? I’m curious. Wolfers does point to this NPR report from last month, so my guess is that someone noticed it and pointed Wolfers to it.

From the NPR article:

The Commerce Department updated its policy for promoting a “culture of scientific integrity” in January 2025, days before Trump’s second inauguration.

A new Trump administration order bans the Census Bureau and the Bureau of Economic Analysis from using statistical “noise,” or data for fuzzing survey results, to protect people’s privacy in their statistics.

The 2025 version included bans on attempts to shape or interfere in data collection, statistical analysis and other scientific activities “against well-accepted scientific methods and theories or without scientific justification.”

The department’s policy, the 2025 version said, involves ensuring scientific findings at its agencies “are not suppressed, delayed, or altered for political purposes and are not subjected to inappropriate influence,” as well as making sure there’s “independent review of facilities, methodologies, and other scientific activities as appropriate to ensure scientific integrity.”

That language is missing, however, in the Trump administration’s revision of the policy, according to an NPR analysis of text posted on the Commerce Department’s website.

And while the revision adopts a definition for “scientific integrity” that is similar to the previous version, it no longer says that “protection from inappropriate influence” is among the “hallmarks of scientific integrity.”

Spokespeople for the Commerce Department and Census Bureau did not respond to NPR’s requests for comment.

I guess the strategy of dodging comments worked, at least for awhile, because for three weeks nobody else seemed to have picked up on this story.

NPR continues:

While most of the public may not be familiar with the policy, Nancy Potok, a former deputy director at the bureau who has also served at the Commerce Department, sees the removed language as “a major change that eliminates the guardrails against political interference in the statistical and scientific data products of the department.”

Potok has been tracking how statistical agencies have been responding to a years-long, bipartisan effort to make sure the federal government produces trustworthy information. That included a 2018 law that led to a rule known among federal data experts as the “Trust Regulation.” The rule requires that statistical agencies “determine the policies and practices that ensure objectivity of its statistical activities” and produce data that is “impartial and free from undue influence and the appearance of undue influence.”

“The fact that there is a conscious effort to revise the department administrative orders and not incorporate things that are in the [Trust Regulation], instead of going in the other direction, is definitely troubling and needs some explanation,” Potok adds.

Why did the government do this?

For former Census Bureau Director Robert Santos, a Biden nominee, the close timing of the policy revision and the bureau’s release of an unauthored report with claims about noncitizen voting is striking. “It’s entirely possible that this was done to reconcile the Department of Commerce and the administration’s own actions by publishing an external partisan document about voting on the Census Bureau website,” Santos says.

And Wolfers brings on the indignation:

On August 19, the Commerce Department posted a new directive called “Scientific Integrity” — note the scare quotes. . . . They posted this directive very quietly. There was no press release, no announcement, and no press conference. For the first time in his life, Howard Lutnick was quiet. The new version just appeared online. To analyze the changes, I [Wolfers] actually had to go to the Wayback Machine to find the prior version of this policy, because it had been wiped from the Commerce website. There’s something pretty bleak about a country’s rules about scientific integrity surviving only because a volunteer internet archive grabbed a copy.

The Jan 2025 rules are here, and the new rules are here.

What do I think about all this? I’m not sure.

On one hand, the above story sounds horrible, and I think it’s disgraceful how government officials have been throwing around slogans such as “gold standard science” while suppressing reports, promoting discredited or flat-out fake science, and adding corruption to the science funding process, while their friends in the media are resorting to ridiculous defenses of indefensible policies.

On the other hand, this updated document could just be some overly busy bureaucrats trying some stupid idea. Also, if that 2025 policy was such a good idea, why did they wait until 2025 to institute it?

If “Protection from inappropriate influence is a hallmark of scientific integrity” is such an important slogan, where was it in the Census Bureau’s first 235 years? There must be more to this story.

On the whole, though, I guess I’d go with Noem’s Razor here: Never attribute to stupidity that which is adequately explained by malice.

In short: I think it’s reasonable to assume that this new document was motivated by some inappropriate reason, such as a desire to steal or to cover up some past or anticipated future offense, or from a general ideological position opposing objective knowledge and open scientific inquiry, or from a political attitude that independent science should be weakened because it represent a source of power that’s not under control of the government or its allies. Also, though, I guess they’re stupid. Just like the Soviets under Lysenko, an analogy that keeps coming to mind.

There’s an alternative explanation that this is all just a bunch of paperwork jockeys trying to justify their own existence, but Noem’s Razor suggests otherwise.

57 thoughts on ““Protection from inappropriate influence is a hallmark of scientific integrity” . . . not any more!”

  1. Never mind the politics. When talking about “data,” the important, overriding issue is whether to use a singular verb or a plural verb. In the above article, “data” is also an adjective. It may come as a shock to some, but in some fields, e.g., geodesy, the plural of datum is datums. And, I just found out that “datums” is the proper term in needlework as well.
    —————————–
    “To protect their terminology from being confused with computers, specialized fields—like geodesy, mechanical engineering, and precision artisans—intentionally broke away from standard grammar. They created the word “datums” specifically to signal: “We are talking about physical geometry and measurements, not computers and statistics.”

    • When talking about data, it might also be amusing to mention:

      – Data, the fictional character from one of my favorite childhood movies “The Goonies”
      – Data, the fictional character from Star Trek
      – DATA, the techno-pop band
      – Data, a genus of moths
      – DATA, the non-governmental organization founded by Bono
      – DATA, the Design and Technology Academy in San-Antonio

      Thanks Wikipedia for making this, possibly amusing and educational, comment possible!

        • I looked up some data about the Datas and found out that Data from the Goonies is the OG Data as that movie is from 1985 and according to wikipedia Data from Star Trek had his first appearence in 1987.

          Side note: 80’s movies rock! The Goonies, Gremlins, Back To The Future, Indiana Jones, E. T., Star Wars, Stand By Me, Die Hard!

        • Quote from above: “I looked up some data about the Datas and found out that Data from the Goonies is the OG Data as that movie is from 1985 and according to wikipedia Data from Star Trek had his first appearence in 1987. ”

          Interesting datum regarding the dates of first appearances of the Datas!

          Gonna have to remember that for my possible bar named Poolbeer located in Alaska, and the pub quiz I will be orginazing there regularly should it become a reality.

    • Yeah, I don’t know—maybe everyone who read it either agrees with you, and so there’s nothing to say, or they disagree but they have no good arguments against your point so they’re rather not think about the whole thing!

      • I guess it’s just not news because this is consistent with how science has been treated. The bigger news is the proposal to not count “non-citizens” and not collect data on race and sexual orientation (link to NYTimes). They certainly understand that the best defense against unwanted data is to not have the data.

        • Government economic stats have always been heavily manipulated and biased. The main purpose is to manipulate public sentiment. The tricks like “avoid collecting inconvenient data” sound standard rather than novel as well.

          If someone is starting from the premise this a new thing, there is little to learn from any discussion.

          The real story is meta. Why are NYT/NPR/etc telling their audiences about it now, when previously they would avoid, minimize, or ridicule the topic? What does *that* imply?

        • Quote from above: “If someone is starting from the premise this a new thing, there is little to learn from any discussion.

          The real story is meta. Why are NYT/NPR/etc telling their audiences about it now, when previously they would avoid, minimize, or ridicule the topic? What does *that* imply?”

          Ding, ding!

          +1

          And another possible reason why some people do not even engage with the sort of surface level, or possibly even naive or skewed, reporting or opinion pieces anymore, as they may leave out crucial facts, views, reasoning, and more relevant and real issues.

      • Anon:

        You write, “Government economic stats have always been heavily manipulated and biased. The main purpose is to manipulate public sentiment. The tricks like ‘avoid collecting inconvenient data’ sound standard rather than novel as well.”

        I don’t think you’re correct here, at least not for the United States. Federal government statistics have a reputation for high quality, and the Federal statistical agencies have a reputation for seriousness and professionalism. That’s one reason why recent policies have been so disturbing.

        I agree that decisions taken by the statistical agencies can serve political goals. Nothing can be completely insulated from politics. But I see no evidence that “the main purpose is to manipulate public sentiment” or that they “have always been heavily manipulated and biased.” Do you have any evidence for this claim?

        • Sure, GDP includes government spending and CPI ignores where the government spending causes inflation like housing, healthcare, education, stock market, etc.

          Actual – fake inflation = “growth”

          There are of course many other games with hedonics, relative weighting, shrinkflation, estimating then revising stats months later, and so on. But that is the primary one.

        • Anoneuoid
          That is a very strange comment you make. Apparently you don’t like government spending and so find the government statistics distorted because it includes that spending. Despite the many problems with how GDP is measured, I always like to point out that it is essentially equal to the total income earned in the economy. So, while you may think the government spending $X on building a missile should not be counted as a positive (a sentiment I have some agreement with), that $X was income for a number of people. Everybody might prefer an GDP measure that only includes spending/income on goods and services we deem “worthwhile,” but that would render these statistics totally subjective (and political). Instead, the GDP data is consistently collected and largely avoids such subjective judgements. Some still remain and are well known: labor performed outside of markets (e.g. household labor, predominantly performed by women) is excluded and has been the subject of much criticism. But the fact that these cases are well known and relatively few is testament to the fact that these government statistics are less subject to political forces than they could be (I would say, a lot less).

          Similarly, omission of a link between government spending and inflation is an enormous stretch. The connection is not as obvious as you suggest. And, to the extent that government spending does increase the rate of inflation, the real GDP should show less growth if government spending is increasing. Real GDP growth is one of those things reported by the government which I would say is far less influenced by political forces than it could be (or likely will be in the future). Again, there are well known issues: inflation measures usually fail to capture consumer’s ability to substitute cheaper goods/services for more expensive ones, so the CPI generally overstates inflation (this is ignoring the distributional issues which we have frequently discussed on this blog: a more granular view of CPI might reveal very different experiences for different subgroups). It is these known controversies that are evidence of the general high quality of these government statistics and their resistance to political pressure.

          I am not denying that there is government pressure, nor am I saying that these statistics are untainted by such influence. But if you compare past US government statistics with China’s, for example, there is a real difference. And sweeping that difference under the rug makes it seem that these recent changes to the oversight of government statistics are not important. I think that is a dangerous view.

        • Dale, I just happen to be spending time looking at these questions at the moment. You will find some results and discussion including some input from Blair Fix who points out some important political adjustments…

          https://mastodon.sdf.org/@dlakelan/117254295847091960

          I think with a little massaging perhaps, both you and I will agree that the *nominal* GDP is *completely meaningless*. This is because it measures an amount of currency exchanged, but the ability of that currency to buy things is completely left out of the question.

          My student and I built a dimensionless ratio GDP / (cost of buying a certain basket of international commodities each year). The results STRONGLY directly relate to economic consumer sentiment results. Whereas official inflation adjusted GDP PPP numbers were both weakly and *negatively* related to consumer sentiment.

          I think GDP nominal is probably OK, it’s the “real” GDP that’s both *supposed* to be meaningful, and also simultaneously completely fictional.

          Blair Fix pointed out that for example the relationship between nominal rent and CPI rent suggests that the government has imputed a 3x improvement in “quality” of the houses being rented today compared to those a few decades ago. This despite my house being constructed in 1946 and still basically the same floor, walls, electrical, etc. Also, “quality” is both in principle unobservable, and not actually a part of the *price* index. So smuggling “quality adjustments” into a price index creates a completely wrong impression of a hard observed statistic which is in fact complete fiction and negatively correlated with peoples expressed reality.

        • @Dale Lets discuss an exact case. Just saw this:

          The official poverty rate dropped 0.5 percentage points to 10.2% last year, leaving 34.5 million people in poverty, according to data released by the bureau. The decline was the second consecutive annual drop and the lowest rate since the agency began tracking the measure, while median household income rose 2.6% to $87,460, the highest on record dating back to 1967.

          https://www.breitbart.com/economy/2026/09/16/census-u-s-poverty-rate-hits-lowest-on-record-as-incomes-set-new-high/

          Now to me its obvious this is because actual inflation > reported inflation. In fact pretty much every single gov stat looks better when you can make actual > reported inflation. I’m not sure there is an exception.

        • Anoneuoid
          You need to be more explicit with me, because I’m not at all sure what you are saying. Where does the actual inflation > reported inflation come from? It is usually the reverse, according to economic theory. In any case, I don’t immediately see reference to whether the income figures are real or nominal, the latter being irrelevant. If anything, the Brietbart piece and its sources are an example of what happens when politicians will be in charge of government data.

        • Dale, in the mastodon post series Blair Fix points to one of his articles where he compares Census data on rents to CPI rent index, implying that the politburo has declared that housing has tripled in quality and therefore inflation is much less than the increases in price suggest. i think thats insane

          certainly you must agree that a kg of aluminum or wheat or copper or crude oil are all pretty much equivalent from 1990-now? Measured against my commodity index where quality is not an issue, real incomes have fallen to half their 2000 value between 2000-2010 and only partially recovered.

          I’m not against creating a quality index for consumer goods, but I’m very much against smuggling it into CPI which should be strictly the ratio of nominal prices.

        • Daniel
          I would appreciate it if you would point me to the precise place where BLS says the quality of rental housing has tripled. What I found is https://www.bls.gov/cpi/factsheets/owners-equivalent-rent-and-rent.htm which describes what seems like a reasonable procedure and not one likely to have resulted in the change you cite. I’m not saying you’re wrong – I just don’t have the time to chase around sites to see if I can find it. Wouldn’t it just be easier to point to the place where they do what you say?

        • The breitbart article references “real” (ie inflation adjusted) income. You can see the history here:
          https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/mehoinusa672n

          The poverty level mentioned will also be adjusted for inflation using the same values. Do you really think people in the US are wealthier than ever right now?

          Also, the CPI housing link is a great example of actual inflation vs reported (a byzantine model based on questionable survey data).

          This model has obviously been built up ad hoc over the decades due to whatever political pressures, and no evidence it has predictive skill (or is even calibrated at all to reality) was presented.

          In daniel’s link they do try to reconcile with other data and find it doesn’t stand up to scrutiny.

          We could do the same for each aspect of the CPI. Eg do health insurance next, which according to CPI is only ~ 1% of expenditures. However, actual people pay $300+ /mo, implying median income of $30k+ /mo.

          Its just an arbitrary (and byzantine) model detached from reality.

        • Anoneuoid
          I agree that the Breitbart piece used real income – although it was a bit hard to find. The government report had a footnote saying that “historical” data was reported in real terms but the article then talked about the % increase in income from 2024 to 2025. I think they could have been clearer by just saying “real income increased by…” rather than burying the slightly ambiguous definition in a footnote.

          In any case, my reason for responding to your comment lies elsewhere. You ask whether I “really think people in the US are wealthier than ever right now?” Talk about an ambiguous question. Yes, I think some people are wealthier than ever. No, I think some people are not wealthier than ever. What about on average? What about the majority of people? What about the lowest quintile? So many different ways to approach this question that it is meaningless to ask without more specificity.

          I also object to your portrayal of these measures. Yes, all measures of incomes and prices are fraught with issues. Yes, they are all subject to potential political manipulation (my interest in the whole post to begin with). But your wholesale discarding of all government statistics involving these measurements is classic Anoneuoid. Let’s reject all such data until it is proven to predict well – it eludes me as to how we are going to accurately predict whether a particular CPI measure tracks what things “really” cost? Where is the ground truth measure we can use to validate this?

          Decades have been spend refining these imperfect measures. Most of the issues raised on this blog about these measures are not new to the producers and consumers of these government statistics. How to measure prices has a long and rich history. This does not mean that our measures are great, nor does it mean they can’t be improved upon. But you appear to label them as some combination of useless and politically biased. I think that does an injustice to the history of these statistics. The very fact that we can have alternative measures developed and debated is testimony to the fact that we have high quality data to begin with. Nobody would waste time debating the way the Chinese government collects income data – much more attention is spent trying to validate whether the measures correlate with anything real (such as energy use). The granularity of the debates about US government statistics is evidence of a level of quality not true in more autocratic places. Unfortunately, the above change in production of government statistics casts doubts on whether the future is destined to move in that direction.

        • I aspire to have Dale’s level of patience. His tolerance for dealing with people who are indulging in blatant motivating reasoning is off the charts.

        • Hi Dale, sorry previous messages were largely written on my phone and finding the reference was not that easy, but I’m on my laptop now and can get it for you… here’s where Blair Fix constructs a timeseries of nominal rent prices using Census data, and compares to the CPI Rent index… The series goes back to 1940, and in that time period the median US rent diverged from the rent price index by a factor of about 3. Looks like maybe a factor of 2 since 1970 by eye. Note the logarithmic y scale on the graph

          https://economicsfromthetopdown.com/2024/10/23/the-american-housing-crisis-a-theft-not-a-shortage/#fig-rent-quality

        • Decades have been spend refining these imperfect measures. Most of the issues raised on this blog about these measures are not new to the producers and consumers of these government statistics

          This is the strange part. How much time and energy has been spent on these models? And they are still presented without any kind of metric demonstrating they are at all connected to reality.

          Its just leaving out the inconvenient data. Almost like the purpose of these models is to gaslight the majority that their standard of living is not dropping as wealth/power concentrates at the top.

        • Anon
          Contrary to Will’s comment, patience is not a virtue I get accused of having. Perhaps in contradiction, I’ll respond to your latest. I believe the history of things like the CPI are in stark contrast to your claim that “they are still presented without any kind of metric demonstrating they are at all connected to reality.” I read the history of their research on measurement issues as there has been an ongoing an deep concern with matching their measurements to reality (https://www.bls.gov/osmr/research-papers/2022/ec220100.htm is just one of many examples – https://www.bls.gov/osmr/research-papers/2010/ec100050.htm is an even better example).

          You state that it seems like the “purpose of these models is to gaslight the majority that their standard of living is not dropping as wealth/power concentrates at the top.” I am willing to believe that there is some truth to this, just as their is some truth to notions that technological progress has generally positive net benefits or that modern life is “better” than life in the 1800s or earlier centuries. This is a bias built into most disciplines and most of modern education. But I think focusing that problem on government statistics of income and price levels is misplaced. With some exceptions (documented in the critiques of these statistics), the history is more of a genuine attempt to improve these measures.

          Measuring “power” is perhaps the most difficult, with “wealth” far behind but well ahead of “income” or “prices.” I’m not aware of any good quantitative measures of “power” – it could just be my lack of knowledge of research done in, say, sociology. I don’t think economists have done an serious studies to measure the distribution of power. I do believe sociologists have spend much more effort grappling with that – but in the absence of any reliable measurement methodology. Feel free to take that on – I wouldn’t know where to begin. I can say I am wealthier now than at any prior point in my life, and I feel more powerless than ever before. Take that dose of reality for whatever it is worth.

        • Dale.

          If you accept my assertion that a kg of aluminum or wheat or a cubic foot of natural gas or a pound of chicken or corn are pretty much the same product as in 1970 or 1990 or 2000 or pretty much any other time, then *factually* my measure showed that americans with an average income (gdp/capita) could buy around half as much basket of commodities in 2010 as in 2000 (I showed the graph in log scale in the mastodon post and I can’t easily attach the non-log-scale version here, but when I look at my pdf in 2010 the US gdp/capita normalized to commodity prices was less than half what it was in 2000, it rose to about 90% in 2019, then dropped almost to 0.5 again during the post-covid era. It recovered to around 90% by 2025)

          GDP_PPP on the other hand had a steady upwards climb with tiny dips in 2009 and 2020.

          GDP_PPP has a *negative* relationship with OECD consumer sentiment. When it goes up, on average that decreases sentiment a bit, but very noisy… explains like 10% of the variance over 26 years… GDP normalized to commodity prices explains like 70% of the OECD sentiment data variance, and is positively correlated.

          “people think they’re worse off as GDP_PPP goes up” is counterintuitive if GDP_PPP is truly a “real income” measure. “people think they’re better off when GDP/commodity basket goes up” is both true, and not at all surprising if GDP/commodity_basket is in fact a consistent measure of income.

          Note, that GDP/commodity doesn’t work equally well for all countries, but it’s shockingly good for most of the major western countries that are comparable to the USA… such as France, Spain, Finland, Belgium, Portugal etc.

          I haven’t solved the mysteries of the universe here, just measured income relative to a consistent basket of fundamental goods that everything around you is made of… doing that blows the entire govt industry of CPI out of the water at explaining consumer’s opinions of the economy. That’s not nothing. It’s also consistent with Anoneuoid’s perception of the CPI world.

        • Daniel
          I’ll have to take a fair amount of time to unravel this, but your statement
          “americans with an average income (gdp/capita) could buy around half as much basket of commodities in 2010 as in 2000” I find about as absurd as finding that more attractive parents produce girls as offspring 70% of the time (in sample of 3000). I don’t know what “ground reality” you are looking at, but I don’t see anything like that. Now I know you are more sophisticated than that, so there is (much) more going on in your estimates, so I will need to look more closely. But I don’t believe the average American lost half of their real income from 2000 to 2010, unless your price adjustment includes the quality of government leadership.

        • Daniel
          I just saw your comment about the Fix analysis. I’ll investigate the links. But my first look seems like his black line (nominal rents) is not inflation adjusted and his red line is real rent, including the quality adjustments you are referring to. But doesn’t it also include measuring rent in real terms? In other words, the red line includes an adjustment for inflation and an adjustment for quality, so the gap between the two lines is not just the quality adjustment????

          As I said, I haven’t had time to look carefully, but that was my first impression.

        • Dale, his black line is the median nominal dollar rent paid in each year based on amounts reported to the Census. His red line is the CPI rent index which should be proportional to some kind of quality adjusted nominal rent, so that the ratio of different CPI values is the inflation factor for rent over that period between the two different values. The ratio of black to red is basically the quality adjustment.

          In other words, the claim is that what a person in 1990 is paying nominally for rent is about 5x what a person in 1940 was paying (red line at 5) for equal quality dwelling. Actual 1990s nominal rents were about 15x the 1940 values (black line is about 15) but this extra 3x increase in nominal price is because the 1990s dwelling is 3x the quality, and if in 1990 you moved into something that was equivalent quality to 1940, you would only be paying 5x (red line).

        • Dale, as for the purchasing power of commodities, we are using commodity data from the IMF available online. we take a basket of fixed quantity of commodities. Based on spending the GDP/capita in 2000 on each commodity we get a quantity, then we weight them in such a way that the basket costs GDP/capita in 2000, basically 1/3 weight is materials like aluminum, copper, sawn wood, rubber, iron etc, 1/3 is raw energy such as crude oils, Natl gas, propane, and 1/3 is food such as wheat, corn, vegetables, and poultry

          we calculate that basket price for every year, and divide GDP/capita each year by that basket price… between 2000 and 2010 Americans lost over 50% of their purchasing power thats either a fact or our data sources are lying.

          the index we make explains ~70% of variation in OECD consumer sentiment and visually just follows the consumer sentiment quite strikingly. The graphs are in the mastodon post series.

          Americans could buy less than half the commodity basket size in 2010 vs in 2000

        • Daniel
          That brings up memories of the energy basis of value promoted by Nicholas Georgescu-Roegen in the 1970s. While sound in some respects, what never made sense to me and what doesn’t make sense to me about your approach, is why this particular subset of goods and services should be the basis for measuring purchasing power. If we were to develop a price index for humans in the year 1000 BC, it would probably contain very few goods and they might all be related to hunting and fishing (or maybe land cultivation). As society gets more sophisticated (I intend to value judgement with that term – it is merely descriptive of more complex production processes), those underlying goods comprise less and less of our budgets. Today, farmers receive a tiny percentage of what is spent on (mostly highly processed) foods. Even if the raw agricultural products rise substantially in price, there will be little impact on most of what people purchase.

          So, I’m not sure why the cost of these basic materials is a good way to measure the cost of living. In fact, I don’t believe it is. It reflects a particular view of the world dominated by the belief that there is a set of fundamental products that are the real measure of value in the economy – and not the values we observe in markets. If I were going to invent my own personal value system, I would heavily discount much of what people spend their income on and I would increase the valuation of a number of things that markets (and people) tend to undervalue. But my personal set of values do not match those of most people. While exercises based on alternative sets of value can be quite interesting, I don’t think of them as objective in any way.

        • Dale, my measure isnt THE objective measure of income, its *one* objective measure of income. objective because it doesnt involve anything other than observed factual data.

          Youre right that theres no reason to think this is somehow the primary “correct” way to value income, which is why we went looking for whether or not it relates to reported consumer sentiment. It knocks that consumer sentiment relationship out of the ballpark, with R^2 nearly unheard of in social sciences (for many countries)

          so thats a reason to believe it measures something real.

          it doesnt work equally well across countries, and of course adding gini into our model works better since countries can vary in how much inequality there is.

          Economists have accepted the false dichotomy of either you know what is the true values or you accept that its all just vibes. This is obviously false, a dead person can’t consume anything and there are biophysical requirements for life. so a sufficient quantity of food, shelter, and healthcare are lexically required before you can consume ebikes and Hollywood movies and concerts. There are other reasons to believe that prices do not represent value across all goods. Instead they measure power. However commodities are generally less associated with power. Another reason to favor the commodities approach.

          Ask yourself why does my commodities real GDP measure work both better in explanatory power as well as *in the correct direction* compared to PPP and yet you still argue for PPP as if it were the careful principled model? its NEGATIVELY correlated with reported economic sentiment…

        • Daniel
          I wouldn’t hang my hat on your R-square relationships between consumer sentiment and measures of real income in the OECD over time. There are several serious measurement issues here. I’m skeptical of the consumer sentiment measures to begin with. But, given that we know money doesn’t buy happiness, it isn’t clear that a close relationship between sentiment and real income indicates a good measure or a poor one.

          The OECD is not a huge number of countries and we know that cross-country comparisons should account for a host of potentially important explanatory variables. It sounds like your R^2 of .71 is from time series data – if so, I don’t find that unheard of at all. Time series data across a small number of countries often yields close fitting correlations. If your claim is that your measure shows this close relationship and GDP_PPP does not, then we’re back to the first point above. There are also major issues with using PPP for cross-country comparisons, though I am not an expert in these measures by any means.

          There are any number of things here which are amenable to further analysis and I am not seeking to defend the way that government measures of consumer prices or income. But if you propose a measure that says real incomes dropped by 50% between 2000 and 2010, my response is that this does not represent ground truth by a longshot. I find that about as realistic as some of the outrageous claims we have discussed on this blog (e.g. attractiveness and birth sex, sports and longevity, and much of the nudge literature).

        • Dale, unlike most economists I don’t believe in such a thing as “real income”, I believe there are a variety of important types of purchases that people make, and the way that prices move in those general baskets are all important and multidimensional. I believe shelter, food at home, utilities, transportation, childcare, healthcare, clothing… are all significantly more important to people than entertainment, restaurant, concerts, luxury handbags, luxury vehicles, etc. I think this is absolutely unquestionable and reflected clearly in the data (the total quantity spent on just basic housing, food, utilities etc vastly exceeds entertainment). I believe there are biophysical laws that make it so that will always be the case for the forseeable future.

          That being said, you don’t have to “believe” in my measure of GDP/commodity prices, it’s just a FACT that if you tried to buy containers full of a mixture of materials, energy sources, and food and you did so with an entire GDP/capita of money, that you’d have bought 1/2 as much in 2010 as you would have bought with your GDP/capita in 2000. Saying you don’t believe it is like saying that you don’t believe that a 3×5 inch notecard is 16% of the paper area as an 8.5×11 sheet of paper.

          Unlike PPP and CPI adjusted “real income” which include a large number of *in principal unobservable* “quality adjustments” chosen by who knows what government politburo process, the measure I show is from entirely objective “how much you actually could have bought in the international commodities market” numbers.

          Half. You could have bought half. That’s simply a fact. We can argue about the relevance. I’m fine with that, but we can’t argue about the quantities (unless you have information that the data sources are lying).

        • Daniel
          I think your data only reflects that raw commodities (meaning agriculture, fishing, minerals, energy – no finished goods and services which all use these) have increased in price – but remain a small part of the overall economy. The commodity price index increased by 142% from 2000 to 2010, and has increased another 47% since then. The value added of these sectors (agriculture and minerals, including oil) increased by 115% from 2000 to 2010 and another 45% since then. Commodities as a percentage of GDP has been essentially 2.1% over that entire time frame. So, yes, if you focus your price index on these underlying commodities, I’ll agree with your facts that we could buy half of what we could in 2000 in 2010.

          The connection to consumer sentiment is far less convincing. I don’t think consumer sentiment is driven by 2% of the economy, so it becomes important to see what is happening in the rest.

        • Daniel, I don’t understand why you’re using GDP at all. I can insert the old joke about Ben Bernanke and Paul Krugman paying each other thousands of dollars to eat dog poop, and the GDP going up by thousands of dollars and 2 jobs being created. In the real world, GDP is going up, but wages are essentially stagnant. GDP is about production/output, not income.

          I think you were on the right track when you were using dimensionless measures of income compared to expenses. This is the only way to track what ‘real income’ means. I believe in the history literature they also use similar measures, like ‘how much wheat can you buy with your wage’, ‘how many calories can you buy’, which are also useful for inter-country comparisons.
          Here is an example of such a comparison (annoyingly, in this 20 page paper, he does not differentiate between real wages and GDP/capita until page 13 or so, but then he starts doing it):https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/journal-of-global-history/article/abs/dating-the-great-divergence/2D62AE94CB238334483770D76A501BF5

          GDP is bad, and consumer sentiment is bad, so why correlate them with an R^2 value (which is also bad, see section 2.2.1.1 of https://stat.cmu.edu/~cshalizi/ADAfaEPoV/ADAfaEPoV.pdf)?

          Consumers ARE suffering since 2008, though. A dimensionless measure of such (in the vein of your earlier views) is in this book: academic.oup.com/book/1464

        • Dale, the first sale of commodities may indeed be 2% of the economy. But to first approximation, if I snapped my fingers and dissolved Meta, Google, Apple, Microsoft, Netflix, spaceX, and a host of similar smaller companies… noone would notice 6 months later. However if I snapped my fingers and dissolved the market for the commodities I’m using to first approximation 98% of the population of the planet would die in less than 3 months. (no food production, no food transportation, no repair of vehicles or housing or roofing, no electricity production)

          Meese, this started purely as an excuse for my student to learn how to use SQL, it became a serious research project once we saw a number of extremely interesting suggestive results. so hopefully we will expand the analysis a bit. One reason to start with GDP is that there are many available dataseries where interesting things are given as percentage of GDP. for example wages, or housing expenditures etc. we will get a bit more sophisticated once we figure out which data series we want to include and where to get them.

      • Daniel
        I’m not sure how much longer we should keep this going – I am not going to convince you of anything and I don’t mean to ignore the considerable thought you have put into this. But I think your approach is seriously misguided. I agree that food, energy, and minerals are very important to human life, despite them comprising a small portion of our national income. I think you would agree that water is important as well. I used the CPI for water, sewer, and trash services along with per capital disposable income to derive a “real” per capital disposable income measure, where “real” means adjusted for the prices of these essential services (which are an even smaller portion of our national income). The result is that, measured in today’s dollars, real disposable per capita income went from $82,351 in 2000 to $70,807 in 2010 and is currently at $69,536. I suspect if I could find a free time series for just the price of drinking water, the declines would be more precipitous.

        The point is that pricing “essential” things to create a price index, regardless of their share of economic activity, is misguided for several reasons. First, what is “essential” is a very subjective matter (although I think we could probably agree on a set of things that are most essential – probably less so on the inessential things). Each person would favor a different price index focused on their judgement of essential. Then there is the matter of whether the prices are being measured correctly. When it comes to water, the world has historically underpriced water, largely ignoring the quality of water and generally under-pricing it. Third, such “essential” price indices, by definition, produce a view of real income that ignores the vast majority of economic activity. While much of this activity you (and I) might view as wasteful or unnecessary, their prices are the result of people’s decisions. And, if we discount those decisions as being manipulated by a small wealthy elite, we head even further down the road of recasting the world in our own image.

        Apologies: I was trained as an economist. While I reject much of mainstream economics, one thing I still believe is that redefining “value” to mean what I believe rather than what people reveal through their actions is a waste of time. The end result can only be to create an alternative worldview that bears little resemblance to the “ground truth.” If only we valued child care and the arts properly, we would see the world so differently than what the economic statistics claim. And so on. I spend (too) much of my life lamenting other people’s tastes – creating measures that mirror my own seems misguided to me, unless I really believed I could convince people to see things my way (maybe that’s our real difference – I’ve mostly given up trying to do that).

        Now, you do link your created price index to consumer sentiment – a worthwhile attempt to tie it to “ground truth.” But I don’t find it convincing. I’ll agree with your analysis that the current measures do not correlate with consumer sentiment, but the fact that you can find some significant correlation in cross-country time series data does not convince me that your measure really captures what is on people’s minds. When people are focused on the price of groceries, they really have no idea what the price received by farmers looks like nor do they care. The fact that measures of consumer sentiment correlate with the prices of a small set of essential things that consume a small part of our income seems like a spurious relationship to me.

        • Dale, its not just that the commodities are necessary to life. Theyre also necessary to all the final products that make up the GDP, how much furniture could you buy without sawn hardwood, steel to make saw blades, energy to transport the wood and run the furniture making machines? How would the furniture makers make the furniture without wheat and vegetables and meat to feed them? How much could the machines do without the copper windings of their motors?

          Multiply this by the same story for every single object you can see around you. Literally we chose the material and energy inputs for 90% of all goods you own. Even if humans can magically survive without the food consequences there isnt a single economic goods production pipeline that would make anything at all in the absence of these commodities.

          That you dont see this materialist view as real and somehow pretend that Cars or Kitchen Cabinets or Shoes matter while the literal steel, copper, energy, rubber, polyester and soforth they are made out of dont matter (since they are only 2% of the economy) is where we vastly differ.

          Beyond their essential nature to the production of virtually every final good in the GDP, commodities are also traded internationally in an incredibly competitive market and so their prices are more like the mythical free market ones economists imagine.

          Disney+ subscriptions are literally entirely built on violent extraction of rent. The economic free market price of a streamed movie is obviously as close to 0 as makes no difference. There are enormous amounts of GDP which involve virtually nothing associated with free market prices. housing rent, IP licenses, automobiles, healthcare, etc. They dont reveal preferences, they reveal the way in which people can point guns at each other.

        • None of those activities are possible without water either. Or disposal of sewage. I don’t disagree about the set of essential things for life – I disagree with creating a price index based on these things and using that to estimate the purchasing power of income. I think the real problem is the price of these essential things. They are market prices (albeit with a heavy hand of government regulations). I believe they are underpriced by markets due to extensive externalities that are necessarily associated with these mostly environmental services. Market failures are endemic. So, if you want to advocate that their prices are lower than they should be, I’m in agreement. I’d also agree that the under-pricing of most environmental resources leads economic growth, income, and wealth to be overstated – possibly by a very large amount. But I don’t think you will get an accurate picture of this by focusing the price index on the market prices of this subset of essential services. You can test this a bit by imagining a scenario where the prices you are using were to decrease. It isn’t hard to imagine agricultural prices and mineral prices declining – perhaps due to technological changes, or due to relaxing of government regulations (happening now). Your index would show that our purchasing power has increased! To me, that clearly indicates a problem with prices, as well as a problem with creating a price index based on these prices.

        • Dale –

          One thing that struck me reading through this thread is how hard it is to talk about these questions in general terms. Any change in discretionary income relative to overall income seems like it could vary enormously depending on individual circumstances – where you live, family situation, childcare, housing costs, etc. So I’m not sure how useful it is to make broad assessments, as we see in this convo.

          But I think that question connects to something you touched on above. Having more material goods, or more wealth overall, doesn’t necessarily mean having more latitude or control over the circumstances that affect you. That seems relevant to your aside that you’re wealthier than ever but feel more powerless than ever. I wonder if what’s changed there is less a loss of power than a loss of agency?

          That makes me think of a related thread a while back with Phil, who was saying it’s important to remember that people are living in larger houses, watching better TVs, and driving better cars – power, in a sense. The German term Verschlimmbesserung – “improvements” that make things worse – comes to mind. Gaining that kind of power can be accompanied by a loss of agency underneath it. And the question of how much discretionary income we have, and how it interacts with agency and power, can be hard to track and is very subjective.

        • Dale, the fact that you think water prices and disposal of sewage are ridiculous ways to measure income is hilarious to me. All you’ve done is convince me that if I had water price data I should add it to the basket. honestly if I had water price data in the dataset I already would have added it to the basket. Electricity same. Sewage is a little more complex. its obviously not a market good, its run typically as a regulated public utility, so prices arise in a totally different way.

          Anyway, I think we have reached a bit of a limit here. Perhaps your bigger problem is that you think I’m framing this as “a true measure of income” when I’m not, I’m framing it as a ratio in essence of the outputs of an economy to the inputs. Its a measure of value added in some sense. If we aren’t adding a lot of value compared to the past its hardly any wonder people would have sentiment going down?

          Real GDP also should be a measure of value added, its the final goods produced, so thats added right? but it doesnt take the cost of inputs into account.

        • Daniel
          My last comments – necessary, because I have 3 issues with your comment. First, yes you should add water, sewer, etc. to your index. In fact, this is the way such indices are constructed – by trying to capture some sort of market basket. It is just that you want to create a market basket that includes what you view as essential. Even though I agree with most of what you feel is essential, I think such a “essential price index” will not be a useful measure of prices that reflect most people’s standard of living.

          2nd, GDP absolutely does take the cost of inputs into account. But, as I’ve said before, the market measure of prices for those inputs is a big issue, since a case can be made that the environmental inputs are systematically underpriced.

          3rd, your statement “If we aren’t adding a lot of value compared to the past its hardly any wonder people would have sentiment going down?” I find unsupported and probably wrong. Sentiment may be going down for a host of reasons. I looked at the consumer confidence surveys, and among many other things, it looks like the distribution of individual responses has been shifting over time. Instead of smooth unimodal distributions, they are looking increasingly fragmented and flattened (as well a polarized when aggregated by income, race, education, etc.). I think part of the systematic decline is due to polarization. It is also due to loss of agency (as Joshua suggests). It may be partially due to people feeling that their work is not adding value, along the lines that you suggest. But the idea that the price of these essential services is rising faster than income has little to do with increasingly negative sentiment. At least that’s what I believe.

        • I don’t mean to ignore the considerable thought you have put into this.

          Regardless of who is right, considerable thought isnt a good heuristic for value. In fact, the success of science was largely the result of accepting that 1500 years of (theological) “considerable thought” was worthless and could be largely disregarded.

          Same with these CPI models. Imagine trying to model something without offering evidence of calibration/anchoring/predictive-skill as the main justification.

        • I’m with Anoneuoid here in terms of I don’t believe there is a “real income” that is a well defined single observable, and I think anything we define should have a purpose in terms of relating material conditions of production to material conditions of quality of life as observables. I don’t find the CPI/PPP calculations satisfactory in that they seem ungrounded in any relationship between those statistics and human experience, and while I don’t think sentiment surveys are the be-all end-all of consumer experience, at least there is a predictive strength for GDP/commodity basket which in contrast GDP_PPP is almost completely untethered from.

          I will happily look at other measures of typical welfare, such as homicide rates, homelessness rates, birth rates, drug abuse rates, leisure spending, whatever. I will bet money that PPP statistics will work poorly compared to the models I’m contemplating in which gdp/commodity is a central number.

          I tentatively consider GDP_PPP or GDP_CPI adjusted or GDP_deflator adjusted as tantamount to religious dogma. There are lots of theoretical reasons why people use various baskets, various quality adjustments, various transformations or imputed rents, or whatever. In the end all of these because they are *in principal unobservable* become excuses to adjust things in order to basically show some kind of exponential growth as needed by elites in order to provide support for their general continuation with their favorite policies.

          Most of the hard facts should be good. Nominal GDP is ok-ish. While GDP considers rent of a dwelling as “production” I strongly disagree with this fundamental concept. This is pure rent extraction by force, similarly for sales of intellectual property services (streaming, music industry, etc). So at a conceptual level I disagree with things Economists take as dogma. Even nominal GDP is therefore unfortunately conceptually suspect for various reasons but at least given the definition it should be an in principal verifiable calculation from observable facts. That is, I disagree maybe with the definition of GDP, but given the definition, nominal GDP should be something one could observe to be correctly calculated from data alone.

          Nominal money supply should be quite good, nominal debt levels etc etc. But anything designed to model “real” income etc is immediately suspect unless its based on very specific stationary observable baskets of goods with highly liquid highly information symmetric, highly competitive markets. Quality adjustments, imputed rents, and soforth all make the “real” versions unobservable “beliefs”.

        • Daniel, Dale,

          even though your discussion seems to have come to an end, I want to try to reconcile your positions. I believe they are not so different afterall and your disagreement about what truly matters to consumers comes down to picturing different situations.

          To make things more concrete, imagine a middle class family of five, with three teenage boys who play video games all day long and a family income of $10.000. Let’s assume the family spends 10% of their income on food and 20% on video games (all of the three boys always need the newest games and biggest screens etc.). Now, the nominal prices of food and of video games double. What matters more to this family? The doubling of food prices or the doubling of video game prices? To Dale, the doubling of video game prices matters more, because the family spends a larger share of their income on it.

          Daniel on the other hand imagines a slightly different situation. It is the same family with the same spending patterns and prices rise just as before but now the family can not afford both the food and the video games anymore. They have rent to pay, the car is expensive and they want to take far-away vacation once per year. They have to make a choice: what should they do? I believe they are wise to cut back on video games. Cutting healthy food is a bad idea and will have negative consequences. Cutting back on video games may not be so bad, even if the boys disagree.

          So in this sense, you are both right and have been focusing on different aspects. It is true that we can not look simply on the price of water and conclude that consumers are dramatically worse off because it doubled: maybe consumers only spend 1% of their income on it. But at the same time, price rises of essentials like energy and food weigh more than price rises of luxury goods, simply because as living beings we absolutely need shelter, healthy food and clean water. We can and should not cut back on these essentials. When it comes to video games and luxury handbags, on the other hand, we can and maybe even should cut back.

          BTW I really appreciate your passion and patience in discussing these things. As Andrew likes to say, measurement is one of the most important issues in statistics, and this is a prime example of it.

        • huan
          Thank you for trying to reconcile these issues. I’m not sure it worked, but it does raise one issue that hasn’t emerged much in the discussion – the thorny issues of measurement. If the 10% of this poor family’s income is spend on food and it doubles in price – and if it is truly essential – then they will be forced to spend twice as much as before on food and severely cut back on video games. I think we all agree with that – and they would be foolish (and unhealthy) to do otherwise. Let’s imagine what the family’s spending pattern looks like after those 2 prices double. $2000 on food and now only $1000 on video games, a quarter of what they were spending before. I suspect their consumer “sentiment” would take a big hit, along the lines of the correlation Daniel finds.

          But, in reality, there are all kinds of substitutions that the family can make. They still need to eat, but they can substitute chicken for beef, generic brands for top brands, etc. Perhaps they can avoid the doubled price of food and still eat adequately (perhaps even more healthily) spending only $1500 on food (more than before in $, but less in quantity). Video games will still need to be cut from $2000 to $1500 with the prices doubled – still bad for sentiment, though not as bad as without substitution. The more they can substitute in each of these sub-baskets, the more they soften the blow of the doubled prices, though it may not feel like that. That forces our measure of essential goods to become ever narrower if we are to avoid issues of substitution – but that results in these essential goods comprising an ever smaller portion of our income, making the link with consumer sentiment and real purchasing power weaker and weaker.

          The CPI (and its constructors, e.g. BLS) have always grappled with issues of substitution. Market baskets change over time, and there are many debates about whether they change enough or too much. Wholesale dismissal of these efforts (which I perceive Daniel and Anon to be expressing) do not jive with the serious attention this difficult issue poses. I won’t say that attempts to improve the CPI are devoid of political influence and bias, but I believe many of these issues have been approached seriously with the attempt to get closer to ‘the truth.’

          Now, ‘the truth’ is elusive, despite Daniel and Anon insisting that it is the only way to validate measures of inflation or purchasing power. The consumer sentiment survey data is offered as possible ground truth, but I have serious doubts. For example, consider https://www.federalreserve.gov/econres/notes/feds-notes/tracking-consumer-sentiment-versus-how-consumers-are-doing-based-on-verified-retail-purchases-20250424.html where the FED compares consumer perceptions with their actual (that is ground truth) spending. Consumers systematically mis-perceive inflation and their own spending patterns. I would like any measures we use to reflect ground truth, but unfortunately, such truth is hard to come by. We have no choice but to invent measures, examine their performance, and try to improve them. Anon seems to believe that there is no attempt to evaluate the accuracy of these measures – I don’t agree. The BLS (and others) has grappled with such issues throughout its production of the CPI (e.g., https://www.bls.gov/opub/btn/volume-1/consumer-price-index-data-quality-how-accurate-is-the-us-cpi.htm).

          I’d like not to rekindle the debate about what a good measure of ‘essential’ prices are and how/whether these are related to consumer sentiment. What I do want to push back against is the portrayal of all of the effort that has gone into official government statistics of prices and income as completely politically driven or misguided. Daniel seems to adopt that position as part of the police power of the state and wealthy rent-collecting elites. Anon seems to adopt that position as the misguided or poor scientific practice of all of the researchers involved with these statistics. I don’t find either of those positions helpful.

        • Dale, to be clear, I dont disagree with the idea that we may want to invent unobservables which help us model things. I’m a Bayesian! What I disagree with is the idea that we publish them as if they were measurements.

          Measurements may have some measurement error. Maybe sentiment is based on 20000 people not 340M, I dont find that problematic. Nevertheless the measurement involves only observable physical facts. On such and such paper survey forms such and such marks were made… Similarly for CPI, on such and such days at such and such locations govt employees purchased such and such quantities of goods for such and such dollars…. These are all physical facts about the world. They are ultimately, questions of the positions of atoms and electrons.

          The “quality” of a rented house is nothing of the kind. The quality of cars is nothing of the kind, etc.

          Dimensionless ratios of dollars paid as income to dollars paid as expenses are the right way to describe the observable facts about the world. Electrons (or dollar bills) moved from such and such storage location to such and such storage location. Thats what it means for payments to be made. Thats ground truth a banker could verify for us.

          Until Economists begin to accept that only such things are “observations” they won’t be serious scientists. Imagine if I published a list of astronomical observations and every time someone else tried to verify them they were wrong, but my excuse was that I made corrections because I was accounting for the position in the minds eye of god.

          This is what “real GDP” is.

          Now, I’m happy for us to invent quality metrics etc. Publishing those as separate data series seems reasonable, as long as they have a Bayesian probability distribution expressing the variation in our belief about such things. Maybe 100 samples from the time series expressing the theoretical variability in the s quantities. But if we did that, and if we were serious about it, we wouldn’t know whether “real GDP” declined from 2000 or increased. the sign wouldn’t even be resolvable, much less variation in magnitude.

          Therefore “real GDP” is a lie, a fiction, or if you like, one particular sample from a WIDE probability distribution cherry picked to balance the interests of elites.

    • Quote from above: “It’s weird to me that there are no substantive comments on this post.”

      I usually dislike most talk about politics, politicians, news events, etc., so I don’t commment on those things usually. On top of that, certain topics and people seem to be associated with significantly more sub-optimal or bad or manipulative writing and discussing by originators of the text or source and by commenters subsequently discussing this text or source. I don’t have the energy or will to go into all of that, but here’s just one example that may make something clear.

      This is a quote from a person who wrote something talked about in this blog post if I am understanding things correctly:

      “On August 19, the Commerce Department posted a new directive called “Scientific Integrity” — note the scare quotes. . . . They posted this directive very quietly. There was no press release, no announcement, and no press conference. For the first time in his life, Howard Lutnick was quiet.”

      Now, for me, these few sentences alone might have an undertone and subtle or not so subtle word use that really annoys me and make it seem like I am reading something from a lawyer or politician or con-artist. I don’t have the energy and will to try and find out why this person uses these kinds of words, or whether they are appropriately used, etc.

      Why not simply write or talk about the directive and what is good or bad or the same or different between the new and the previous version and leave sentences like “for the first time in his life, Howard Lutnick was quiet” out of things. I don’t know whether that is true, and I don’t have the energy and time to try and figure that out while I am trying to understand this directive and what’s possibly different and how and why.

      Another example from this short quoted section is the following. Why write “note the scare quotes” here in this section? What is the point of that? What might that do to the reader? If I look at the linked document dated august 19th the title Scientific Integrity on top is without scare quotes, and at the beginning of the document the crucial terms are defined under section 3 using scare quotes to indicate them which seems pretty useful to me. What’s the big problem here? Am I missing something about the scare quotes? Why have I now spend time and energy reading and thinking about scare quotes?

      Anyway, this is just one section, and these are just a few sentences, etc. It’s all so tiresome for me seen from multiple perspectives, so I don’t even read things like this anymore, which in turn results in me not commenting on the substance. Perhaps it’s not even deserving of the term “substance, perhaps it’s just slop or porridge written by AI and/or some dude with psychological issues and a lack of proper discernment and capabilities. I don’t know who all these people are writing all these things and I don’t care.

      Anyway, I rather put my time and energy in other things, like wondering whether it is appropriate and useful to ponder why it looks to me that university students aren’t being educated well (enough) in logic and reasoning. At least, I did not receive a proper education in this if I remember correctly. Could such things be useful for many other things aside from scienctific activities as well, for instance with assessing a piece written by some dude who writes some stuff on his newsletter website?

      • Quote from above: “Could such things be useful for many other things aside from scienctific activities as well, for instance with assessing a piece written by some dude who writes some stuff on his newsletter website?”

        Logic and reasoning seems pretty important to me, but I am no expert. Again, I wasn’t educated in this all so I may make mistakes here, but please allow me to say one more thing about this all using the topic of the blog post as an example.

        Here’s a section quoted in the blog post:

        “That language is missing, however, in the Trump administration’s revision of the policy, according to an NPR analysis of text posted on the Commerce Department’s website.

        And while the revision adopts a definition for “scientific integrity” that is similar to the previous version, it no longer says that “protection from inappropriate influence” is among the “hallmarks of scientific integrity.””

        Now, if I am looking at the definition of “scientific integrity” in the document dated august 19th I can see the term with “scare quotes” (or simply “quotation marks”) defined as: “Scientific Integrity” is defined as the adherence to professional practice, ethical behavior, and the principles of honesty, objectivity, and transparency when conducting, managing, peer reviewing, using the results of, and communicating about Scientific Activities and Scientific Information.”

        Now, what does “protection from inappropriate influence” have to do with this definition of “scientific integrity”? Perhaps that protection could be seen as a pre-requisite or a wish or who knows what, but from a certain perspective one could argue, and perhaps even clearly see, that it has little to do with the actual definition of “scientific integrity” and with the possible emphasis in this definition on the actual behavior and principles and responsibilities of people.

        So, perhaps a different focus (maybe even a more appropriate one) on a certain definition and interpretation of scientific integrity might already explain some things here. I don’t have the energy or will to go and investigate more than I already have, but do want to note that the document seems to further state tthat: “This Order otherwise is in addition to, and does not alter the requirements of any other applicable federal statutes, regulations, or policies, or other Operating Unit or Department administrative orders. These include, but are not limited to:”

        A list then follows of a whole lot of things that perhaps might be about “protection from inappropriate influence” in one way or another. I don’t know what is meant with that exactly, but one of the things referred to is something called 2CRF part 200 where a lot of things can be read that might have to do with “protection from inappropriate influence” concerning certain situations or scenarios. For instance:

        “Costs incurred in attempting to improperly influence, either directly or indirectly, an employee or officer of the executive branch of the Federal Government to give consideration or to act regarding a Federal award or a regulatory matter are unallowable.”

        As might often be the case, it could be useful when discussing things to define terms. Sometimes that already makes things clear, or provides some clarity, or makes writing or discussing something more fruitful.

  2. For those interested: “The manipulation of official statistics as corruption and ways of understanding it” (2021) by A. V. Georgiou

    “It should be noted that the goal of manipulation of official statistics is to alter the perception of the reality that these statistics are supposed to depict so as to serve certain political interests. Thus, the manipulation of statistics can take the form of altering the statistical results themselves or it can take the form of altering the perception of the statistics. 9 Thus corruption in official statistics can appear with both these forms of manipulation, and the phenomena that are included in the present typology include phenomena from both these forms and not just from the ‘expected’ one – i.e., distorting the numerical figures themselves.” (p. 92)

    This paper mentions some examples of manipulation of official statistics in Box 1, and makes a distinction between certain types which I will now summarize:

    Type A phenomena include the use of the ‘crudest’ instruments in the manipulation of official statistics:

    1. Direct alteration of statistical results
    2. Not applying existing standards
    3. Suppression of statistics

    Type B phenomena include the use of what may be considered as more ‘sophisticated’ instruments in the manipulation of statistics:

    4. Selective use of upstream data
    5. Withholding upstream data
    6. Indirect modification of methodology on ad hoc basis
    7. Managing existing standards
    8. Distorting the form of the release
    9. Suppression of the production of statistics
    10. Undermining the credibility of official statistics

    Type C phenomena include the use of the most ‘sophisticated’ instruments in the manipulation of statistics:

    11. Biased standard setting

    • The paper you are referring to offers a number of examples of government corruption of statistics from several countries. I think it is worth noting the US example where the government official responsible was demoted as a result. We know that countries differ greatly in corruption (e.g. https://www.transparency.org/en/cpi/2025). So, I think it is important to consider that paper in the context of Anoneuoid’s comment above (and Andrew’s response).

      I accept that government statistics are subject to political forces. What is – and what is not – reported is influenced by politics, as well as the accuracy of these statistics. While I believe that is true everywhere, I do not think it is equally true everywhere. The problems are more severe in some places than in others. This post is specifically about a change in US policy regarding statistical collection and reporting. Officially removing the veneer of scientific oversight and replacing it with explicit political oversight is a major change. And, while Anon may say we should never have trusted any government data to begin with, I think that is a mistake. This recent change erodes whatever limited trust was there before. You don’t have to have faith in government statistics, to believe they have some credibility. And they will now have less credibility. Rather than sweeping them all into a grand statement that corruption is everywhere, I think the changes are real and important to recognize. Trust is not absolute, but it is important. And there is now less of it.

  3. Do we know what the pre-2025 rules were? And were they implemented before or after the inauguration? Given what they tried to do to the 2020 census, it was likely an attempt to get ahead of the demands for changes such as not counting citizens or removing access to estimates for small places.

    • Andrew’s post has a link to the old and new rules. You may be right about the Census – but I think that is just one example of the kinds of things that might happen. There are plenty of other government statistics that have strong political implications (anything to do with race, gender, LBGTQ+, American History, climate change,…..)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *