Mayor Zohran Mamdani is expected to propose linking Grand Army Plaza with Prospect Park by closing a dangerous stretch of road between them. . . .
The plan would effectively reconnect the oval-shaped plaza’s most prominent feature, the Soldiers’ and Sailors’ Memorial Arch, with Prospect Park, Brooklyn’s emerald jewel, restoring the 80-foot-tall arch as a grand entrance to the park, as its designers intended.
Cars would be banned from the parts of the southern end of the plaza that border the park, from Union Street to Eastern Parkway, which would do away with a forbidding four-lane crossing, according to the city Department of Transportation. . . .
After public feedback, much of which favored more dramatic changes to the area’s roadways, the Mamdani administration selected a plan that would remove cars from the lower tip of the plaza and divert some traffic to other streets.
They quote people on both sides, who raise a number of points:
Lynda Balsama, an organizer with . . . United Neighbors of Prospect and Crown Heights, said the redesign would divert more traffic to nearby residential streets and add travel time for fire trucks and ambulances. . . .
Between 2021 and 2025, there were 219 traffic injuries along the plaza’s central roadways and outer ring, according to the Transportation Department. . . .
In spite of the constant traffic, the plaza remains a popular destination for those who want to admire the work of Frederick Law Olmsted and Calvert Vaux, the designers of the plaza and Prospect Park (as well as Central Park in Manhattan). . . .
“Every time N.Y.C. D.O.T. has provided more space to pedestrians at the park, it’s been an instant success, and it becomes impossible to think of how the space could have functioned before,” Mike Flynn, the transportation commissioner, said in a statement about the plan. . . .
The Transportation Department also expects the plaza redesign to help speed up some of the slowest buses in the borough, including the B41, which serves over 27,000 daily riders, because the reconfiguration should reduce congestion in and around the loop.
Here’s the official announcement from the city government.
Here are the issues raised above, stated more abstractly:
1. Current public opinion,
2. Worse traffic on other streets,
3. More fire damage (because the fire trucks are delayed) and more deaths or serious health problems (because the ambulances are delayed),
4. Fewer traffic injuries at the intersection in question,
5. Happier tourists and locals who want to enjoy the park,
6. Track record that past pedestrian expansions have been popular,
7. Faster buses.
I’m sure you could think of more; this is what I got from the news article. Of these seven issues, five are pro-redesign and two (#2 and #3) are anti. That doesn’t mean the plan is a good idea, as it reflects the balance among who was quoted. That said, I did some googling and it’s hard to find much opposition to the plan, so maybe the Times had to work to get even that one quote.
In any case, the research challenge is to put numbers on all these things. This still doesn’t answer the question of what to do, as it involves balancing questions of public opinion, economics, convenience, and life and death. But it would be a start. It’s hard for me to imagine that item #3 counts for much at all, but it should be possible to give some estimate of the components that go into it. Indeed, it could be that the fire trucks and ambulances would actually come faster.
Anyway, it seems like a good example, to work through the numbers on the seven items above.
I’m retired now, but I had to engage in stuff like this when I was working. The dreaded Return on Investment (ROI) calculation. In my case, we had to calculate the ROI for costly efforts to prevent failures before they happened. We were told that management would only approve an expense if the ROI was above 3, so we started from 3.2 (gotta cover your tracks a little bit!) and back-calculated, then reported that the effort would prevent x number of failures which added up to an ROI of 3.2. I’m certain everyone else was doing this as well, and my own managers would have been furious with me if I didn’t play by the rules.
I called it the Rule of 3. When doing quotes for proposed work, my supervisor told me to figure out the actual cost, then double it. I called that the Rule of 2.
I get that the world grinds to a halt if we can’t put some sort of numbers on these types of things, but I still think it is all numerology…if only because it was when I did it!
That is a skeptical, though not unrealistic, view. Too often, the analysis gets warped to achieve a pre-determined result. In those cases, I’m not sure the modeling is a positive – all it does is hide the accountability for the decision and limit public participation in decision making. But I’ve always thought that the modeling of a problem like this one – full of hypotheticals and counterfactuals – lies in increased understanding of the tradeoffs and inter-related parts of the problem – not in the “optimal” decision that results from the model. I would want to understand how increased safety and satisfaction of pedestrian visitors interacts with decreased safety/increased congestion of commuters. A model can improve understanding of the tradeoffs without providing an answer of whether or not the proposed change is a good idea. I’d like to think that this is of value, regardless of what ‘side’ a person is on.
This reminds me of Environmental Impact Reports here in California. Supposedly independent consulting companies know perfectly well what the powers that be want, and tilt the analysis accordingly.
The entire eco-regulatory and consulting industry apparatus is a make-work racket and policy justification factory. One of my fav studies of recent years, promoted heavily by certain pols in WA state, reports the amazing economic benefits of removing all the Snake River dams. Of course! :) What could be more amazingly beneficial than removing a bunch of power generation, locks, and all the bulk shipping that goes with it? :) Surely salmon fishing and recreation-driven convenience store sales – the main hoped-for benefits of dam removal – will make up the $5B? cost of removal, the higher cost of rail transportation from one of the world’s most productive farming areas (the Palouse) and the lost power generation!! That’s obvious. Especially when we can count on the same people to generate further studies rejecting new roads and development the region necessary to make all that beneficial recreation possible.
“Scientists” (mostly a meaningless moniker) wonder why people don’t trust them. Heave-ho bro, because this is the kind of crap you do all the time. Academia is no different. Outside of a small number of disciplines where lab results clearly distinguish truth from fiction, academia is inhabited by people who have zero stake in the real economy and see their income as derived from the magical money pot of state and Federal budgets. They are more than happy to find a way to thread their “results” through whatever needle is necessary to impress the right people and keep the cash flowing.
Word has it that Federal employment is down >300K under Trump. Hopefully we can get to 3M before 2028, with deregulation also driving major shrinkage in the consulting industry.
I agree with you regarding the economic analysis of removing the Snake River dams. But I completely disagree with your conclusions. A sound economic analysis will show that the benefits of removing the dams are much less than the costs of removal. This does not mean it is bad policy – it reflects the limits of doing the economic analysis according to the rules of the discipline. I’ve seen attempts to force the economic analysis to say otherwise (by appealing to all sorts of values: existence values, irreversible damages, speculative willingness to pay for all sorts of things bolstered by questionable surveys, etc.) and do not find them convincing. But the exclusive focus of economic tools on measuring “value” as either willingness to pay or willingness to accept compensation is not equivalent to the only relevant analysis. Ethics and morality matter – at least to some (like me).
You clearly are ignoring these dimensions and there is nothing “scientific” about ignoring dimensions of the decision problem that do not fit a particular (and limited) disciplinary perspective. I do agree that failure to identify the limits of a discipline undermines its legitimacy. It is a sad state of affairs that the desire to promote some policies (in particular, environmental protection/preservation policies) seems to require forcing the economics beyond its boundaries.
” there is nothing “scientific” about ignoring dimensions of the decision problem”
Well put! There is a form of willful idiocy in which someone first argues that a complex problem is actually quite simple, followed by the “obvious” solution to what has now been carved down to a simple problem. In a lot of cases, the general flow is that only the extrinsic values really matter, and only fools worry about intrinsic values.
Anonymous –
> ““Scientists” (mostly a meaningless moniker) wonder why people don’t trust them.”
It’s interesting how often I come across this from very online people. A quick Google says, from an Oct. 2025 Pew poll:
“…at least a fair amount of confidence in scientists to act in the public’s best interests.”
Scientists: 77% confidence
Military: 75%
Police officers: 70%
Public-school principals: 70%
Religious leaders: 57%
Journalists: 47%
Business leaders: 37%
Elected officials: 27
Why would I trust the opinion of someone who projects his own views to determine what “people” do or don’t believe?
Different anon here. I don’t agree with that guy, but I wonder how much most people trust social scientists vs physical scientists. I bet they trust social scientists less.
Googling, I found some British data:
“There is a big problem of trust in the opinions of economists, particularly among people who have not studied economics (55%), among older age groups (54% of 65+ age group) and residents of the North of England (44%) and among Leave voters in the EU referendum (54%). Half of the respondents (50% excluding don’t knows) think that economists express views based on personal and political opinion than on verifiable data and analysis.”
https://economicsnetwork.ac.uk/research/understandingecon
Anon2:
The worst is when physical scientists say really stupid things regarding social science, as here.
Although, to be fair, social scientists sometimes say really stupid things regarding physical science, so it goes both ways.
Both of the above perpetrators are members of the prestigious National Academy of Sciences, so unfortunately this is happening within the core of the scientific establishment.
I’ll trust a lot of scientists, but I won’t trust all of them, especially not the ones who end up being prominently featured in the news media. There’s also this Ariely guy . . .
Anon2 –
Sure – it wouldn’t surprise me if there’s varying levels of “trust” in different kinds of scientists. But I’d still say that Anon1 has a problem with his statement in a broad sense.
Two related aspects.
1) From what I’ve seen, there’s also a political signal in the polling on “trust in scientists” in the US. The trends also differ by political orientation (used to be relatively higher on “the right” and lower on “the left,” but that relative balance has largely reversed – mostly because of a drop in “trust” among the segment comprising the farther reaches of “the right”).
2) I think more generally what we might be talking about is largely related to institutional trust – more so than trust in scientists themselves. Dan Kahan did some interesting work related to this, where he interrogated the question of what “trust in scientists” means:
https://www.culturalcognition.net/blog/2014/4/28/science-and-public-policy-who-distrusts-whom-about-what.html?utm_source=chatgpt.com
He was writing about this back in the dark ages (2014), and it wouldn’t be surprising to me if things have changed. But… some tidbits from that article:
“Well, how would you feel if your child told you he or she was marrying a scientist? About 70% of the public in 1983 said that would make them happy. The proportion who said that grew to 80% by 2001, and grew another 5% or so in the last decade.”
And:
“Today around four times as many people say the government is spending too little on scientific research than say it is spending too much.”
There are different things we might mean when we talk about “trust” in scientists, and I don’t think it’s safe to assume that the polling question is capturing some general, undifferentiated attitude toward scientists themselves as opposed to largely, political identification, particularly towards institutions broadly, and government-adjacent institutions in particlar.
According to Thomas Wolfe, “Only the Dead Know Brooklyn”
https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/1935/06/15/only-the-dead-know-brooklyn
but that was written before even I was born and that refers to subway transportation. The females in my family are fanatically and politically active opponents of automobile transportation in the Twin Cities; banning cars is a constant topic in my home.
Andrew –
> “It’s hard for me to imagine that item #3 counts for much at all.”
Why. (More fire damage (because the fire trucks are delayed) and more deaths or serious health problems (because the ambulances are delayed)…seems quite plausible to me – unless you have something specific in mind as to why the delays wouldn’t be significant.
Joshua:
Yes, I guess I didn’t phrase it well. Fire damage, deaths, and serious health problems are indeed important. It’s just not clear to me that the redesign would really be expected to increase response times for fire trucks and ambulances. When streets are redesigned (which happens sometimes), I suppose that the fire department and ambulances come up with new routes, and this will result in faster service in some settings and slower service in others. It seems like a big jump to assume that this redesign would lead to a net slowdown in service.
I’ve read about cities greatly reducing use of sirens on ambulances because the aggressive driving leads to accidents, and apparently for ambulances at least an extra few minutes of travel time typically has no effect on the outcome. Fire might be different.
Not to mention all the fire and ambulance runs that won’t be needed when the accidents right there are reduced dramatically. So maybe it helps reduce response time.
My guess is that it would depend mostly on specific traffic patterns and that speculating without those details has limited utility.
Maybe there’s not a lot of extra traffic, even though the change would be nonzero. I have no idea of any relevant numbers, I’m just speculating. The historical argument seems to favor banning cars from that part (they did it before in similar situations and it was fine).
Traffic pattern changes can be remarkably subtle. My condo complex has a feeder road onto a high-traffic parkway, and it was always frustrating to find a gap to be able to do a left turn. There is a 4-way signal light a 100 yards to the left, and one day they put a left-only signal for traffic turning into our direction. Naively you would think this would make it worse, directing more traffic our way, but what it actually did was to bunch up the traffic and put more gaps into it, and suddenly it is not as hard to get on to the parkway anymore.
Sometimes those traffic engineers do know what they are doing!
I don’t know anything about this specific scenario, but in the UK removable bollards are often used in this situation and emergency vehicles carry a key for them.
Apparently the traffic bollard was first used in 1721 at Waltham Cross in Hertfordshire to protect a medieval monument from carriages. I’d like to think that the traffic cone was also invented in England, considering our deep joy when encountering this item of carriageway furniture. Sadly, it was invented in LA in 1940.
The modern descending (into the roadway) traffic bollard was invented in France in 1984.
(who says that AI doesn’t have its uses!?)
As someone who makes mathematical models as a job, this seems impossibly difficult. So, my questions:
1) How would one “put numbers on it”? Specifically, what metric space would be used? Would it be a vector space? Would the sample space map to the reals?
2) How do you know this model isn’t inherently chaotic? That is, the results that you get are going to vary significantly depending upon the initial conditions. Or — this is how I interpret “chaotic” — the mean and variance will be equivalently the same for each model that’s used. Boarding an airplane is one example of what I would call a system that’s chaotic. Regardless of which model is used, almost all boarding times (the time it takes to load all passengers) is approximately the same to any other model.
In any case, if anyone responds, I’d appreciate an example of a simplified version of this problem that was successfully modeled — a mean and variance was found.