For some reason the other day I was thinking about summer camp, and in particular the names of some of the campers: Travis Levi, Tony Kiefer, Patrick Amory, Southy Grinalds, Rusty Zorbaugh, . . . I remember very little about the actual kids. Some I liked, some I didn’t. I’m not in touch with any of them. Once on the street several decades ago I saw someone whose face looked familiar, I think my face was familiar to him too, we looked at each other and said hi but then were puzzled and walked away. I think that was Travis Levi but really I have no idea. The names, though, they have an emotional resonance for me. Not because of the people attached to them; it’s more the sound of these names that carries the feeling.
The resonance of these names reminded me of Stephen Vincent Benet’s classic poem, “American Names,” which begins:
I have fallen in love with American names,
The sharp names that never get fat,
The snakeskin-titles of mining-claims,
The plumed war-bonnet of Medicine Hat,
Tucson and Deadwood and Lost Mule Flat.
And ends with the beautiful stanza:
I shall not rest quiet in Montparnasse.
I shall not lie easy at Winchelsea.
You may bury my body in Sussex grass,
You may bury my tongue at Champmédy.
I shall not be there. I shall rise and pass.
Bury my heart at Wounded Knee.
Which made me wonder, who is the Stephen Vincent Benet of today? Back when I would go to used bookstores 40 or 50 years ago, there would often be some dusty hardbound volumes of his poems and stories on the shelves—I guess his books sold a lot of copies in the midcentury period. I think he’d be considered a “middlebrow,” to use the terminology of the time—here’s a good essay on the topic by literary critic Louis Menand. Benet was kinda classy, kinda folksy, took life and literature seriously but with a sense of humor, but lacked some depth; Dwight Macdonald described his book-length poem, John Brown’s Body, as “sometimes solemn, sometimes gay, always straining to put it across, like a night-club violinist.” That’s a problem with book-length poems in general—I’d say the same thing of Vikram Seth’s The Golden Gate, for example. But Seth’s a novelist, not a proclaimer in the mode of Benet.
Here’s a good and unfortunately anonymous mini-biography of Benet, which concludes, “The measure of his achievement, however, is indisputably John Brown’s Body, a poem whose naîveté and conventionality in themes, techniques and viewpoints are raised, by the greatness of its subject and Benét’s devoted craftsmanship, to the level of high folk art.” That seems about right.
I’m thinking that maybe the closest match to Stephen Vincent Benet in recent years is . . . Alice Walker? Successful writer of serious books that are not pulpy but are not quite considered all that as literature, public figure, a conscious representative of America in some way. I’m not sure, but maybe that’s the best fit, recognizing that literature as a whole has a much smaller cultural footprint today than it had a hundred years ago. Another possible match would be Stephen King, who fits into the “folk art” and “Americana” slots but as a massive bestseller has played a different role in our culture.
The late poet Mary Oliver is very popular with NPR middlebrow types. She wrote about nature a lot (“Wild Geese,” “A Thousand Mornings”).
Amanda Gorman has not, to my knowledge, produced any long-form poetry, but from what I know of her work it is similarly lyrical, uncomplicated, and middlebrow serious.
He’s been dead now for 40 years, but Archibald MacLeish’s verse play J.B. was required reading when I was in high school, which I take to mean sufficiently accessible to possible count, if not “today.”
I started Lonesome Dove recently, so I nominate Larry McMurty. A very vibes Western USA book. In the introduction Larry laments that he thinks of it as a pretty insignificant book, but it ended up pretty popular. I heard about it on a podcast and then found it at a local library, so it is well known enough that it is still available and discussed after 50~ odd years.
He also mentions in the introduction he meant it to be a story about a bunch of largely regrettable and rough characters, but it seems to have been received as an idealization of the West. Not sure if that is relevant for the categorization here (or if it’s just part of what makes a Western a Western).
Jorie Graham should be on the short list.
https://poets.org/poet/jorie-graham
https://www.poetryfoundation.org/poets/jorie-graham
Marky:
Given all of Graham’s awards, I’m thinking she might be too highbrow to be a good comparison to Benet. Also, poetry today takes up a lot less of the culture than 100 years ago, which is why I was thinking that a novelist today would be a better Benet match.
Interesting comment, Andrew.
Wrt poetry today vs a century ago…check out Google Ngrams Viewer for the word ‘poetry’ from 1900-2019. The trendline doesn’t lend strong support to your supposition. It’s more likely that poetry has never been a prominent feature of popular culture, not then, not now.
Too highbrow because of her many awards? Another way to think about this is that these awards are recognition of broad popularity.
If novelists are a good benchmark today, might not film directors also qualify?
I’m thinking of Scorsese, his wide appeal and incredible body of work. Imagine, he and DeNiro were childhood friends growing up in Lower Manhattan. Together, they built a monumental oeuvre from Taxi Driver to The Irishman, the latter being a summa on that work. Jesus on the cross cried out, “Consummatum est” (It is finished.) Scorsese had DeNiro’s character dodging the finality of the grave and, in the last scene, asking his priest/confessor to leave the door to his room ajar.
Marky:
No, Scorsese is too good to be a match for Benet. He has middlebrow and highbrow popularity, and in that way Scorsese more comparable to a literary figure such as Robert Frost, who had broad popularity and was also respected by the literary elite.
The match for Benet has to be someone who’s more of a folk artist who produced work that is not considered “great” or even, in some ways, good, but had high middlebrow respect in its time.
I think the lack of responses highlights that no one really fits the bill! Stephen King might be the best choice, but as you note he’s not a great fit. Larry McMurtry shouldn’t count, since he isn’t alive. John Grisham?
If one changes the category to non-fiction or film, it’s a much easier task!
Raghu:
Maybe the best current or recent matches to Benet would be some pop musicians who have that same folk-art feel. Or filmmakers. John Hughes could almost work, except that, like Stephen King, he’s almost too popular to be a perfect match to Benet. Various filmmakers could fit the bill here, in that serious and popular filmmakers are often explicitly or implicitly playing with modern myths the way Benet did. Benet followed in the steps of Walt Whitman and was consciously American—John Brown’s Body, The Devil and Daniel Webster, etc.—and Hughes was pretty much deliberately exploring modern American archetypes of the suburbs.
According to Wikipedia Benet died in 1943 — well before 50 years ago, so I don’t think McMurtry being dead disqualifies him. I like John Grisham, but doesn’t feel distinctly American or anything (if that’s a requirement). I think you could put a John Grisham character in Sussex and they’d be more or less the same character.
Pop music artists? Jay-Z, Beyoncé, Taylor Swift?
Not at all familiar with Stephen Vincent Benet, so maybe I’m missing some key characteristic, but what you have described sounds a lot like Jonathan Franzen (_The Corrections_) to me.
Franzen’s appeal is more to those whose brows are arched
How about building a recommender system for Benet? By default, such a network would score similarities for all the artists in the data.
What would such an algorithm require?
Easy, Bob Dylan.