The incredible shrinking SSRN page

I was going through comments on this morning’s post which involved the amazing productivity evidenced by the list of preprints here:

But then when I was checking something, I saw that something happened:

The number of papers dropped from 259 to 99!

Then when preparing this new post, I checked again:

And again:

I guess someone’s running the bot in reverse.

P.S. It’s down to 44. I wonder what the story is.

P.P.S. Down to 1:

The lone remaining paper is “Sequential Bayesian Pricing of AI Infrastructure,” posted 29 May 2026.

P.P.P.S. And now the page is gone. I guess the experiment has concluded, or the impersonation has been stopped, or something.

P.P.P.P.S. According to this commenter, it was SSRN that took the papers down.

27 thoughts on “The incredible shrinking SSRN page”

  1. Another strange thing: the supposed correct SSRN page lists him as an Associate Professor, but his official University of Chicago page lists him as Robert Law, Jr. Professor of Econometrics and Statistics, an endowed full professor. Will the real Nick Polson please stand up?

  2. Last night I sent him this email: Dear Professor Polson,

    I write at lukeford.net. I have no credentials. I’m working on a piece
    about your SSRN output this year and about Theories of Human
    Connection in particular, coauthored with Vadim Sokolov, posted March
    11, 2026. Andrew Gelman discussed it on his blog yesterday. I’m going
    further into the documents than he did, and I’d like your account
    before I publish.

    Specific items:

    Jeremy Horpedahl counts 258 papers posted to your SSRN author page in
    2026 through August 26, 104 of them in August. Is that count accurate,
    and were all of them posted by you or with your authorization?
    Was generative AI used to produce Theories of Human Connection or
    others among the 2026 papers? I find no AI disclosure in the PDF or on
    the abstract page, and SSRN requires disclosure of material use.
    The abstract and Chapter 10 assert that Gottman’s models predict
    separation with over ninety percent accuracy. That number is a fit to
    the original sample, not a prediction, as you would know better than
    most. Do you stand behind it?
    The preface lists sixteen thinkers, including yourself, between
    Nisargadatta Maharaj and Katherine Woodward Thomas. Chapter 1 says
    fourteen. Table 13.1 lists twelve. You do not appear in any chapter or
    in the references. Can you explain the inclusion and the
    discrepancies?
    Two references appear corrupted. Buunk, Dijkstra, Fetchenhauer and
    Kenrick is given as 2008, Personal Relationships 15, pages 271 to 278;
    I believe the paper is 2002, volume 9, same pages. The Bhagavad Gita
    is listed as Anonymous, 1944, Penguin, London; the Penguin edition is
    Mascaró 1962 and the 1944 translation is Prabhavananda and Isherwood,
    Hollywood. Do you know how these arose?
    Separately: arXiv 1804.10043, revised April 29, 2026, concludes at
    Theorem 25 that every non-trivial zero of zeta lies on the critical
    line, and the abstract says the Hardy and Ramanujan growth bound is
    verified using Hayman and Grosswald. You retracted On Hilbert’s 8th
    Problem from the Brazilian Journal of Probability and Statistics in
    2018 over an error in applying Grosswald’s result. Has that error been
    repaired in the current version, and if so, where?

    Luke Ford
    lukeford.net

  3. Why are the papers being removed rather than analyzed? Love of analysis and truth has given way to jealousy and pettiness. Andrew you are a bully.

    • Shiva:

      No bullying is happening here. We’re just reporting on unexpected things we’re seeing on the internet. When 258 papers authored by a well-respected researcher appear out of nowhere, that’s news. And I don’t think anyone’s expressing any jealousy here.

      Regarding the question in your first sentence: I have no idea! I don’t know who posted the papers (or, perhaps more precisely, who programmed the bot to post them), nor do I know who took them down. If you have any idea who removed the papers, you can ask them directly. Otherwise, I can’t tell you where they went.

      • Andrew you are lying when you claim that you don’t know who removed the papers. You were gloating and taking screenshots like a bully in 3 rd grade. Not only are you jealous and a bully but now you’re lying. Next you want to understand how the papers were done so you can poach other people’s ideas and processes. That makes you an intellectual thief. LOL.

        • Shiva:

          I’m not doing any lying. When responding to your earlier comment, I indeed had no idea who was taking the papers down from SSRN. Later I saw the comment on the other thread from Vadim which said that it was SSRN who took the papers down.

          Nor was I gloating. This episode does not make me happy. I posted the screenshots to document what was happening, as this is an unusual event, and without screenshots it’s hard to document what was going on. It’s not bullying to take screenshots.

          Nor am I jealous. If other people want to post 258 papers on SSRN or whatever, that’s their business. It’s not a business I want to be in, and I have no jealousy about it.

          Finally, not to worry, I’m not planning to poach this process. I don’t think there’s really anything here to steal, so you can rest assured that I’m not a thief either.

          I get that you’re angry. I hope you can consider that, if someone’s going to post a few hundred papers online in a few months, then other people might look at them, they might have some negative comments, and they might even wonder how it all happened.

          Also, it may be convenient for you to blame me, but I’m not the one who posted the 258 papers and I’m not even the one who first brought this to the world’s attention. That would be the econ bloggers here. You can also look at all the comments on this thread and elsewhere. I’m far from the only person who considers this story to be bizarre and troubling.

  4. Now I’m even more confused,especially given Sokolov’s comment (in the other post). Were these ‘legitimate’ papers (not talking about quality, but about authenticity)? Why did they disappear? Why are there 2 accounts for Polson? Sokolov makes it sound like these were real papers, the culmination of long term research projects. I could believe that except for the volume. And except for the ensuing removal of the papers. Something looks amiss here. And Sokolov’s own web page includes a link to an AI course he teaches which I found quite innovative and along the lines I have been thinking about AI. So, he clearly is knowledgeable and very interested in AI, something I can believe Polson might share. All that makes me go back to the experiment explanation.

    • Dale:

      From other comments on these threads, it seems that Polson may think he’s proved the Riemann hypothesis, which suggests that he might be delusional about his mathematical contributions. Combine a delusional but persuasive statistician and an enthusiastic AI expert and you could see how the result could be hundreds of junk papers.

      • If you follow the link given by Chris above. You will see a person giving a talk the transcript of which begins, “welcome to uh my talk on the uh short proof of the riemann hypothesis.”

        A search on the terms Polson and Reimann yield a number of hits. Several of them address the validity of his proof. I didn’t see any of them, other than those authored by Polson, that considered the proof valid.

        His claims go back several years. Given his background as a serious scholar, it seems to me to be highly likely that his proof has been reviewed by some good mathematicians.

        Bob

  5. If the Sokolov and Shiva Maharaj comments are real, this story is even weirder than it originally seemed. It’s also interesting that Polson is at the University of Chicago unleashing torrents of AI-generated articles, while elsewhere on campus, concurrently, AI is being banned in undergraduate social science core classes and first-year law courses.

    • Raghu:

      I guess that, once someone’s proved the Riemann hypothesis, the University of Chicago will let him do what he wants. Fair enough: a hypothesis like that doesn’t get proved every day, or even 258 times a year.

    • Until Sokolov showed up my thought was some sort of citation farming system. As I understand it Google Scholar will count citations to published work if uploaded to SSRN. Thus, if you want to bolster your citation count all you need to do is churn out 258 papers that cite your actual, published work! The appearance of the co-author defending the papers puts a bit of a wrench in that theory but I still consider it highly plausible.

      • Allan:

        Sure, but what would Polson gain from getting 258 or even 2580 more citations? He’s tenured and is already wherever he’s ever going to be in his career. At this point it’s gotta be about the work, not the cites.

        • I don’t think Polson was intended to be the prime beneficiary but rather a grad student he favored (or some other beneficiary could have had dirt on him I suppose). While we cant be sure of the motivation I feel it’s more plausible that citations were the goal rather than proliferation to demonstrate the power of AI + prompts or as some sort of social experiment. Certainly would help my theory if we could cross-reference the citations used in the papers against the work of his grad students. Alas, they are no longer available, and too much time has been put into this by now.

          At any rate, it’s incredibly bizarre.

        • Allan:

          My best guess right now is that Polson had these 258 ideas that he wanted to write about and that he’s been so AI-pilled that he thought that using the chatbot to extend them to full-length papers would be the best way for him to explore these ideas and get them out there. Seems crazy to me, but he could just be taking AI hype a bit too literally. Under this hypothesis, Polson wasn’t doing it to help anyone personally; he just thought this was the most effective way to spread the word.

        • I don’t think I’ve had 200 ideas in my whole career! Having more than 200 in my backlog in a single month is not too plausible.

  6. They also have 20+ books on Amazon, independently published between Feb and April 2026. One independent review, flagging it as a scam book. That Shiva person seems to be a chess expert. I do hope this is some social game/experiment. The alternative explanations are fraud or insanity.

  7. Anonymous is not kidding! Among the books published this year by Nick Polson, Shiva Maharaj (presumably the angry commenter above), and Vadim Sokolov, we have “Vedic Math: The Story of Human Mathematical Thought” (published February 2026, 454 pages), “The Green-Eyed Animal: Sexual Jealousy: Its Myths, Biology, Psychology, and Economics” (published February 2026, 452 pages), and “Play Like Tal: A Study in Chaos, Sacrifice, and the Art of Attacking Chess” (published Feb 2026, at only 255 pages).

    I will stop myself before I go down this rabbit hole. But here’s a quote from the Vedic Math Amazon blurb: “Suitable for general readers with intellectual curiosity, students of mathematics and its history, educators interested in alternative approaches to mathematical reasoning, and anyone who has ever known the answer before they could explain it.” It’s great for folks who, say, may know the proof of the Riemann Hypothesis before they can explain it.

    • Excellent comment. I had to at least peek down the rabbit hole. Andrew would no doubt appreciate “The Feynman Principle: The Art of Deep Learning.” The Amazon blurb begins:

      “Most people who believe they understand something are wrong. They recognize the vocabulary, they can repeat the definition, they might even pass an examination — but they cannot explain the idea in plain language to someone who has never encountered it.”

      This is a chatbot writing about humans! I had to quote that one for David in Tokyo.

      I guess we won’t get an explanation as to why Nick Polson thought it prudent to use a different name for all these AI publications. Do the angry coauthors really think all this is OK? Why would I want to read AI slop about the dots you connected when I can just generate the same amount of slop on dots I want to see connected?

      • I’m still voting for experiment. It is too obvious that he used an AI factory and he seems too smart to believe that it was going to fool people. I think it is a disruption of the academic research process, in many ways overdue. When AI can produce endless volumes of stuff (I still don’t think it is all garbage – there are some decent ideas buried in the slop) this easily, then we need to rethink what gets published and how that gets used. I can support the need to rethink these things, but why do it this way? It seems like a poor way to make a point. And then I don’t know what to make of his supposed co-authors comments. The whole things seems strange – but the simple trashing of the work as garbage seems inadequate as a response.

  8. Sorry, one more and I’ll stop. “Menopausal Rage” by Nick Polson, published April 3rd 2026.

    “There is a moment when something shifts. A heat that has nothing to do with a hot flash. You have spent most of your adult life being the calm one, the reasonable one. You are not calm now.”

    It can be yours for only $24.99 at https://a.co/d/009VU7M8

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *